A script that abandons fantasy for a Hollywood taste

Derick 2022-04-24 07:01:16

At the 2017 Cannes Film Festival, a film about European refugees who gained superpowers and escaped from the sky caused a huge controversy. Many film critics thought it was a gimmick to exploit refugees, but unexpectedly criticized the black movie star Will · Smith's favor, he is full of praise for the cool long shots in the film. Although the film ended up being nothing, the Hungarian director of the film, Kenel Mudluzzo, caught the attention of Hollywood and was eventually promoted to Hollywood to make his first multinational production, Fragments of a Woman, in which the heroine Vanessa Kirby won the Best Actress award at the Venice Film Festival last year and has a chance to win the Oscar for Best Actress in the new year.

The screenplay was written by the director's wife, Kata Weber, who is said to have experienced it herself, and was done with the director's personal encouragement. Although the director and screenwriter are representatives of European authors, this new work is obviously different from their previous fantasy works ("Joan of Arc", "White God", "Guardian of Jupiter"), and is closer to Hollywood in terms of plot. s work. Regardless of whether it is restricted by transnational co-productions, director Mudluzzo has not given up his iconic dazzling long shots and symbolic metaphors (apples and bridges). In a set of long shots for nearly half an hour at the beginning, slowly showing the accident that a couple encountered during childbirth at home, the heroine Kirby's heart-wrenching performance (embarrassing movements, painful expressions and miserable screams) gives people With an immersive look and feel, you can realistically experience the pain limit of pregnant women and children.

This half-hour paragraph alone, the heroine Kirby is enough to be called the honor of the actress. However, this sense of immersion created by super long shots gradually cracked after the baby died. Whether the accidental loss of the child caused a rift in the couple's relationship, or the difference between the heroine and the mother's accusation of the midwife, it all seemed so familiar. These highly pre-set plot arrangements are completely caught in the old Hollywood routines, and it is difficult for people to see new ideas. If hero Shia LaBeouf has been pushed to the cusp of recent sexual abuse scandals, viewers may find that some of his actions in the film bear a striking resemblance to the allegations in reality.

This lineup of stars holding the moon (with Vanessa Kirby as the center) is simply a standard Olympic theme, and the sharp topics are presented in the paragraphs that advance in time (the prominent class difference between the male and female protagonists) , the legal issues involved with the birthing midwife). The lines of husband and wife and mother-daughter are written in the same way as conventional Hollywood scripts, except that the independent female image is not prominent enough, and is often submerged in these emotional and expressive narrative fragments, except for the last statement in court. Rather than saying that these "fragments" are for the audience to piece together step by step how the woman reconciled with reality after losing her child, it is better to say that the director and screenwriter have given up the fantasy style they had worked so hard to develop and had to devote themselves to this mediocre and unremarkable style. A script full of calculations.

View more about Pieces of a Woman reviews

Extended Reading
  • Lila 2022-03-26 09:01:09

    7.1/10 The quality is mediocre. Procrastination and lack of light, the childbirth scene led to top-heavy, and the trial as a fulcrum was untenable. The relationship between husband and wife and the relationship between mother and daughter are not clarified. The image of her husband is not three-dimensional. Is it because of cowardice or grief that he chooses to cheat physically and resume smoking and drinking? Is he a struggling father, husband, or a cowardly wretch? The lens language is appreciated, and the long lens is very nice, which is the icing on the cake. The heroine's performance is very dazzling, I think it deserves a performance award. It's not bad, it's mediocre. It bloody presents a family that was already cracked, suffered an accident, and finally fell apart. And a stubborn, kind, strong and vulnerable mother. But the degree of completion is not high, like a punch on cotton, there is no dramatic tension, and it is difficult to infect the audience. Far less than "Manchester by the Sea," maybe my expectations were too high. She erased everything about the child, but she was obsessed with the growth of the apple core, and the pain was hard to let go.

  • Carli 2022-03-26 09:01:09

    Loved LaBeouf's performance. The clumsy and rustic of a blue-collar class, the irresponsible manner of being a man, and the incompetence but complaining about the anger of the sky, all of them are vividly portrayed. Kirby's performances have obvious traces, and more of them rely on roaring moans and superficial crying scenes.

Pieces of a Woman quotes

  • Elizabeth: And I'm ashamed of me. That I wasn't a good enough mother to teach you how to stand up and speak for yourself, for God's sakes. And to deal with this. Like my mother taught me. After my father went into the ghetto, my mother found a shack, an empty shack, that she went into and gave birth to me. Without any help at all. She stashed me under the floorboards when she had to go out and steal food. So she could make milk enough to keep me alive, but just alive. Not strong enough to cry, or we'd be caught. When she finally got me to a doctor, he advised her to just let me go. That I wasn't... I wasn't strong enough to survive. But when she absolutely insisted, he picked me up by my feet and held me up like a chicken and said, "If she tries to lift her head, then there's hope." And you know what I did, Martha? I lifted my head. That's what I'm asking you to do now. Lift your head and fight for yourself, for God's sakes! Go out there and face that woman.

  • Lane: Yes, how did you feel holding your baby you had just given birth to?

    Martha: She smelled like an apple.