Great Phantom

Zechariah 2022-01-07 15:53:50

No one can match Renoir’s prison escape film. What is different from other similar films is that the whole film is always carried out in a relaxed and humorous atmosphere. There is no unthinking discussion of the justice and evil of war. There is not even a villain in it. War appears in a normal state and always follows a civilized one. Rule. Unlike other films, it is either a murderous slayer or a utopian alliance. The
director did not ignore the existence of class. There is always a gap between the nobles and civilians in the same cell, while the high-ranking officers of the two opposing camps can sympathize with each other. At the beginning of the film, we saw German pilots mourning the death of French pilots. It indicates that this is a massacre among rational civilized people. The glory of humanity is everywhere, but it can't stop the guns. The captain of the nobleman is also from another class. Compatriots sacrificed. No one seemed to be keen on killing. The warden performed his duties and the captives always yearned for freedom. Ordinary soldiers in the war just abide by the laws set by the state machinery. The German soldier who finally raised the gun. Knowing that the French fugitive is already there. In Switzerland, we immediately returned to the camp. There is no neurotic sadism in the film. There are no anti-violent heroes.
The justice of World War II often conceals the cruelty of war. But this film describing World War I brings us back to war. The theme itself. War is not a monster. It is indeed a rational absurd law created by us. The film has surpassed countless similar escape films. It has not incited our enthusiasm for the so-called freedom, equality and justice. But it makes people more understand what is humanity .

View more about La Grande Illusion reviews

Extended Reading
  • Shaina 2022-01-07 15:53:50

    Nearly childlike innocence, you have me and I have your humanistic care. It may be the prequel of "The Grand Budapest Hotel" or the key to unlock it in a sense, but like Zweig's European Golden Age, history and this movie are too far away from me.

  • Kelvin 2022-01-07 15:53:50

    The masterpiece of Jean Renoir, the originator of the escape film. 1. Escape as a supplement, the main line is anti-war, the title of the film is a pun, which can refer to absurd and ruthless war, but also seems to memorialize the disappearing European chivalry and humanitarianism; 2. French and German soldiers and cross-class Friendship, harmony, warmth, and poetic; 3. Renoir's depth-of-field mirror and scene scheduling, Stroheim's superb performance; 4. Male disguised as a woman, harmonica, geranium, Switzerland in the snow. (8.5/10)

La Grande Illusion quotes

  • Capt. de Boeldieu: Is that supposed to be witty?

  • L'ingénieur: I hate the way German bulletins exaggerate.

    Lieutenant Maréchal: And our papers don't? Remember "the Russian steamroller"?