It must be inhumane torture that should be killed

Hope 2022-01-10 08:02:40

Supporting torture has achieved a certain purpose, and it doesn’t matter whether it is what it is or not. Torture alone is a kind of torture. The executor, the person being executed and the investigator, such as the physician assistant, the female investigator, and the 183 waterboarder, is he a terrorist or a member of an extremist organization? Others, who defines it, does he know the intelligence or does not know who investigated it, and which one is more effective and more humane compared to obtaining intelligence through torture or non-torture interrogation and obtaining intelligence? For example, it is believed that there are only interrogations that establish rapport: the intelligence obtained by the tape-breaking psychology and psychologists who use verbal insults, burial alive, insects, and waterboarding on the field. This is the problem given by the movie, not just the train track problem. If one day there is a scandal in the world that the use of non-torture interrogation methods is a kind of scandal, then that is the effective method of torture. And conversely, throughout history, the one who should be beaten to death must be the torture and destruction of a living organism to extract a confession. Thinking of using cruel methods to force information and cover up the facts, it is better to use the same social resources to research and use more humane methods to get what you want, because no matter what race or gender, as long as he is a social person, he will eventually have weaknesses. Yes, there are flaws.

Going back to the movie, the movie did not argue whether torture was correct and whether inhumane methods should be used to achieve humanitarian goals. Rather, through investigation (movie plot advancement) step by step, the use of torture has not been effectively explained. In the process of counter-terrorism, EIT (Torture Project) did not find bin Laden, but made progress by other means. The film does not want to simply express the spirit of humanity and philosophical problems. Instead, it tells us that the EIT torture project is simply torturing, and it has not achieved the justice and peace it preaches. It has torn away the false mask of being the country, the home and the people, and runs counter to the values ​​of human society.

To me, this value concept of walking a tightrope is wrong. There is no saying that justice is abandoned for justice to achieve the purpose of justice, and there is no such thing as becoming a demon to achieve holiness in the world for the sake of eliminating demons. If there is this kind of self-sacrificing spirit, one should have the consciousness to become a demon and be beheaded. If not, it is the brave who becomes the devil who harms mankind, and the so-called justice becomes even more evil. Regardless of whether becoming a demon can really kill demons. Society should not be a reincarnation of demons, but should eliminate demons from the beginning and use human means to defeat demons.

View more about The Report reviews

Extended Reading
  • Henri 2022-04-22 07:01:44

    In a refined modern film, the Driver character does not even have any personal emotional involvement; it is found that "justice" in the truth is still safeguarding the core interests of the United States, which is evident from the main emphasis on "promote" and disapproval of Snowden, and in the bipartisan conflict. In this state, the eccentric political inclination will affect the tone of the film, that is, justice can often only be done in a mid-air state: the film is only presenting the truth and does not assume subsequent responsibilities.

  • Carley 2022-03-25 09:01:15

    The publication of this report is an important step in reshaping our values ​​and showing the world that we are a just society governed by the rule of law.

The Report quotes

  • Senator Dianne Feinstein: If it works, why do you need to do it 183 times?

  • New York Times Reporter: If the Times had your report, we would print it, tomorrow.

    Daniel Jones: No. If it's gonna come out, it's gonna come out the right way.