Doubts in "The Rampage of Nagato Yuki"

May 2022-10-24 09:47:50

One of the biggest doubts is reserved in the film: what happened in the three days from the 18th to the 21st will

first be described according to the film flow:

1. On the 18th, after I arrived at the school, I found an abnormality: Suzumiya was not there, Asakura reappeared, Nagato became a little girl...
2. After choosing to repair, Xu returned to 3 years ago, saw Nagato who helped, and got the repair program
3. Xu returned to the early morning of the 18th, witnessing Nagato changing time and space. Later, when trying to inject the repair program into the little girl Nagamon, she was stabbed by Asakura, fell into a coma, and the plan failed. The audience is in a stupor, and is unknown to the situation at that time.

Among them, the information obtained during the coma is: Asakura's fatal blow was blocked (it can be determined to be Nagato, and after analysis, we can know that it must be from Nagato who has the ability in the future), and he was explained by another self. Guessing that the dummy who saved him helped him complete the task , the

suspicious point appeared:

when he was preparing to repair the Nagato abnormality in the early morning of the 18th. It can be guaranteed that there are at least 3 ghosts. One is the ghost who is going to repair Nagato and is ambushing at the school gate; the other is the ghost who is also ambushing at the door, but it is not to prevent Nagato's abnormality, but to save himself from being stabbed. ; There is also the most crucial one: a Xu who slept soundly at home, and who had gained nothing for the world to change.

Back to the beginning of the film: Xu slept soundly in the early morning of the 18th. At this time, what is happening at the gate of the school: just finished changing the world and becoming a girl Nagato; I want to correct Nagato's emptiness, which comes from the emptiness of the three-day space from the 18th to the 21st; one is to save the stabbed by Asakura. My own emptiness, this emptiness is the emptiness from the revised world after the 21st.

So, what happened when Nagato was repaired?

Assuming that Nagato was successfully repaired at that time, then going to school in the virtual morning when he was sleeping, he would not have experienced the world being changed. Xu will not start the recovery process, will not return to three years ago, and will not appear at the school gate in the early morning of the 18th. If you say this, the whole world will collapse: the two ghosts that were ambushed at the school gate in the early morning of the 18th do not exist. Simply put, the history of the world changing from the 18th to the 21st will not happen, and the world that will change the world from the 18th to the 21st. must disappear. The most deadly thing is not here, but on the Tanabata 3 years ago, Xu didn't shout the words "remember john smith" to Haruhi, who was about to go home. This will lead to the disappearance of the entire story of "Suzumiya Haruhi"...

Obviously, it is impossible to

rule out the impossible, and speculate what should happen:

1. I was sleeping soundly at home on the 18th, and it must be in the A world changed by Nagato.
2. If the first rule is established, then the next thing is that Nagato was not repaired immediately
. 3. When I found that the world was abnormal, and when I found Nagato in the Department of Literature and Art, Nagato must not know what happened at the school gate in the early morning. (memory modification or another generalized Nagato)
4. The changed world was repaired, which must have happened after the virtual set sos at the headquarters and pressed enter.

According to speculation, this is reasonable. A cycle has been formed.

Although the certain theorem of time and space works is reasonable, there are still a few small questions:
1. What happened in Nagato of the Ministry of Literature and Art on the 18th, it is

certain that she is not acting. Although it is indeed possible to pretend not to know, but being able to make an expression is something that Nagato, who is capable, cannot do anyway.
Is it Nagato's fixer setting? For example, let Nagato remain normalized, and it will not change back to normalized Nagato until the selection of the repair program is completed. And forget what happened on the morning of the 18th,
or that Nagato was completely repaired that night, and a girlish Nagato appeared again?

2. Is it true or false to be pushed down the stairs?

The awakened Xu must have no idea about this kind of thing. The things pushed are still told by others. An attitude of "It turned out that this script was used."
Assume that being pushed is a real event. Because I was pushed after going to school on the 18th, it means that this incident happened in a world from the 18th to the 21st that has not been changed. This contradicts the story... Because a changed world must exist from the 18th to the 21st. It can be said that the real story of "Suzumiya Haruhi" is triggered by this point. If there was a normal world from the 18th to the 21st, the entire Suzumiya series would not exist.
So the most reasonable assumption is that the fact that Xu was pushed down the stairs did not happen. If it is said that everyone has memories, it is also forged. Only this explanation is reasonable

, and new questions have arisen, but at least there is no contradiction.

I also specially read the novel about the events from the 18th to the 21st. The news is:

After solving the incident on the 18th (after Nagato injected the injection program into the abnormal self), he directly traveled back to the hospital on the 21st.

In the process of crossing, I saw with my own eyes the process of being sent to the ambulance...

However, if other people's memories can be faked, why must the false memories be real?

Of course, I still look forward to more advanced explanations and theories.

View more about The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya reviews

Extended Reading

The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya quotes

  • Kyon: December 16. It was a morning so cold, it felt like if you were to hit the earth with an ice pick, it would break into nice clean chunks.

  • Haruhi Suzumiya: Who are you?

    Kyon: John Smith.