Is this man active or passive?

Melany 2021-10-13 13:06:04

Laura Mulvey believes that in classic Hollywood narratives, men are the active agents who promote the narrative and create incidents, while women are the passive ones who are watched and outside the narrative. In her famous "Visual Pleasure and Narrative Movie", Hitchcock's "Rear Window" was mentioned as an example.

But what active power does this man in "Rear Window" have? All his power seems to be just the power of seeing. His body and actions are severely restricted. When the salesman, the object he has been prying on, came to his room to kill him, he even Can't escape. On the contrary, his girlfriend, the heroine, is a very capable person. Not only did she share all the power of watching with the hero (she and the hero voyeurized the life of the salesman together, their subjective viewpoints were often overlapped). ), and she actively participated in this incident, not just satisfied with "watching", she and the male protagonist's female nurse excavated the corpse in the garden together, and sneaked into the salesman's room to search for evidence. These actions are not the actor's instructions, the actor has been opposed to her doing so, but she is obviously enjoying it.

According to Teacher Li Xun, the narrative of classic Hollywood is often two lines, one is career line and the other is emotional line. The two lines push each other and merge together at the climax of the film. In this film, there are obviously such two lines. The career line is the homicide detection of the hero and heroine, and the emotional line is the love between the hero and heroine.

The heroine and the heroine love each other, the women are even more proactive, while the men have been cowardly avoiding, because she feels that the heroine is too noble and is not the same person in his life. This kind of fear of professional women urges the heroine to become the female image he imagined in order to gain the love of the heroine.

The heroine didn't believe the hero's speculation about the murder at first, but when she saw the salesman packing the box, she suddenly completely believed the hero. Maybe she also had doubts, but I would rather think that she suddenly opened up, this is an opportunity, an opportunity to transform her into the ideal female image of the male protagonist. Since then, the heroine has actively participated in this event. When she went to the salesman’s garden and room in person, she also became the actor’s peeping object, and from the actor’s point of view, she became A female image full of adventurous spirit, wit, smart, and action. This image is what the male protagonist expects and appreciates. When he finds that the female protagonist possesses this image, he inevitably falls in love with the female protagonist.

At the end of the film, when the actor is asleep and he can no longer stare. The heroine put down the detective adventure novel in her hand and picked up the Harper’s fashion magazine that she really wanted to read. So we understand that all her actions are just to satisfy the gaze of the male protagonist and to cater to the male protagonist's imagination of the female image. She and Judy in "Dizziness" are actually the same, they are both in order to get the love of men, and they have built themselves into the image under the prying eyes of men.

Therefore, the heroine in "Rear Window" seems to be active, but in fact she is passive, because her behavior is to cater to the protagonist's prying eyes. The male protagonist seems passive, but as long as he has the power to see, as long as he acts as a gazer, he can manipulate women and change their image with his gaze. Maybe the salesman didn't kill his wife either? But in the stare of the male protagonist with doubts, the salesman is undoubtedly a murderer. This is the power of gaze.

View more about Rear Window reviews

Extended Reading
  • Dessie 2022-03-26 09:01:01

    As an audience who has watched a lot of movies, and who will watch this work 70 years later, they will be attracted by the plot in the movie and really admire Hitchcock's genius. The protagonist observing the opposite behavior through the rear window is like the audience watching a movie, and can easily substitute into the protagonist's environment. In the end, the protagonist's girlfriend commits danger and is discovered personally, which is the climax that the audience expects. Before the end of the film, whether there is a homicide has always been confusing.

  • Jovanny 2022-04-24 07:01:01

    Panopticon-like rear window. From the character setting to the environment setting, plot, rhythm, everything is reasonable, but whether you like it or not depends too much on taste, I personally don't like it. The life that men need is a camera that can look at the lives of others, a stage-like vision. What impressed me was that Stewart was really rude to Grace Kelly, and the heroine even helped to investigate the case in order to attract the attention of the hero. This trend is necessary but embarrassing. Samsung and a half

Rear Window quotes

  • L.B. Jefferies: Why would a man leave his apartment three times on a rainy night with a suitcase and come back three times?

    Lisa Fremont: He likes the way his wife welcomes him home.

  • Lisa Fremont: I wish I could be creative.

    L.B. Jefferies: Oh sweetie, you are. You have a great talent for creating difficult situations.