The 2nd Oscar "Broadway Melody": Is it the worst Oscar best film?

Maxwell 2022-01-21 08:02:14

At the end of the 1920s, in the early stage of the economic crisis, nearly 2,000 banks closed down and many workers were on the streets. However, the film industry is extremely prosperous, and many companies have switched to making sound films. Talents from the Broadway theater, song and dance, and broadcasting industries gather in Hollywood. This seems to be a bit similar to the current economy. It is an era of economic downturn and the death of all people in entertainment.

The 2nd Oscar Best Picture: THE BROADWAY MELODY

Broadway was an important place for American dramas and musicals at that time. Nearly a hundred theaters were gathered on a single street. The "Broadway Melody" filmed by MGM in 1929 was based on the Broadway Theater and described the stage love history of the two sisters on Broadway.

The film cost 350,000 U.S. dollars and became a sensation after it was released. Some of the songs and dances in the film have been widely circulated, such as the theme song "Broadway Melody", "Boyfriend", "You and I Love Each Other" and a wonderful ballet performance. These performances have been selected into the Hollywood Song and Dance Collection. Due to the success of the film, MGM made several sequels.

However, by the standards of modern music films, the melodic level of Broadway is not high. Critics generally believe that "if you score, it may be the lowest score among the best films of all previous Oscars." The emotional lines in the film are rather scribbled, even without, whoever loves or doesn't feel so ridiculous. Beautiful women, cars, champagne, jewellery... created the stage of American dreams in the early twentieth century-the drunken Broadway. Countless people became famous overnight, but lost themselves. Looking back a hundred years later, I realized the meaning of Oscar: the film that best reflects values ​​in the current era. The film itself has no brilliance. After the precipitation of the long history, it allows us to see the United States back then. Maybe this is the meaning of this film.

----Tasting series of classic movies, please pay attention to today's headlines, "Watching Movies and Talking about the World", to be a collection of self-media. Welcome to follow and discuss in the message area.

View more about The Broadway Melody reviews

Extended Reading
  • Renee 2022-04-21 09:03:15

    The first sound film to win the Oscar for Best Picture (2nd), from a modern perspective, the plot, music, dialogue, and sound effects are all outdated, but if you look at it from a hundred years ago, it's amazing! It is said that at that time, the actors were all acting talents, and they could not play without both hands; and modern idol actors only need to show their faces to make fans go crazy.

  • Adriel 2022-04-20 09:02:25

    After all, it was in the 1930s, and it was a film produced shortly after the appearance of sound films, so it cannot be exacted with the current requirements. In general, naive, not just for this film, but also for earlier films. The singing and dancing part of this musical is more focused on group dancing, dramatic conflict, and childish and lovely character dialogue, but the conflict has always been fierce. The performance is now a bit too straightforward, with a strong stage play style.

The Broadway Melody quotes

  • [the Stage Manager is yelling at the electricians in the theater rafters]

    Stage Manager: [pointing to the stage] I told you, I want a spotlight *right here*!

    [a miffed electrician drops a spotlight off the rafters. It lands on the stage with a crash]

    Stage Manager: [cowed] Thank you.

  • Queenie Mahoney: Gee, this is elegant, ain't it!