Elementary: A movie full of holes?
Some people hurriedly watched it and shouted that I was smarter than Jay Chou. I could catch the loopholes of Jay Chou. I saw that this movie had a lot of funnels. How could Xiaoyu talk to Qingyi during the piano fight? Wrong plot? ---------I can only say, you didn't understand, and the movie you saw was very sloppy and sloppy.
1. How to travel through time and space?
You can travel through time and space by playing "Secret" on the piano where the "Secret" score is discovered.
2. Can you be seen after traveling through time and space?
The rule of traveling through time and space is: after traveling through time and space, the person who sees it at first sight can see you.
Therefore, Lu Xiaoyu is not only seen by Ye Xianglun, so there will be a dialogue between Lu Xiaoyu and Qingyi at the time of Douqin, and Dayong sees Lu Xiaoyu running away.
3. Is the time of the two space-times the same?
The answer is yes. Lu Xiaoyu himself also said that the time he came twenty years later was just twenty years away, and it was the same day in a different year.
Lu Xiaoyu's graduation ceremony also happened to be Ye Xianglun's graduation ceremony.
Four or fifteen apples, 108 steps
"One apple a day, fifteen apples, how many days do you think you haven’t come to class?"
Actually , you can only travel through time and space once a day, so Lu Xiaoyu remembered Congqin The teacher arrived at the room exactly 108 steps, closed his eyes and walked carefully, cherishing every opportunity.
In those fifteen days, Xiao Yu might not have come to Xianglun at first sight; Xiao Yu was right in front of Xiang Lun, but he lingered for fifteen days without being felt. What kind of suffering was that. .. ...
Understanding the above rules of time and space, why Lu Xiaoyu walks with his eyes closed, how the paper went to Qingyi, and how Dayong saw Xiaoyu and a series of things are easy to explain.
Intermediate: The perfect ending?
After watching the movie for the first time, most people think that Ye Xianglun has returned to twenty years ago and lived happily with Xiaoyu; in fact, there are secrets...
1. Lu Xiaoyu is dead?
Yes, the evidence is that Drizzle's hair.
Careful people will find that during the period when Lu Xiaoyu has not traveled through time and space for five months, his hair was longer than when he first met Ye Xianglun; the sections that embraced Ye Xianglun and Li Kebai during the graduation ceremony were all longer hair.
But the hair of Xiaoyu that Ye Xianglun saw after traveling through time and space was short, not long!
And it wasn't the day of the graduation ceremony, when Lu Xiaoyu was doing homework; and she didn't seem to know Ye Xianglun, it should be said that she didn't.
Xiao Yu is indeed dead, which is one of the tragedies of this film to some extent.
2. Where did Ye Xianglun go?
Here I need to put forward a concept, different time and space can be regarded as different boxes.
I call 99 years space-time A, and 79 years space-time B.
Most of the length of the movie is about: the light rain B of time and space B travels through time and space to have a love affair with Xianglun A of time and space A, when Xianglun A who knows everything about time and space A also wants to travel through time and space, Xianglun A comes It was not time-space B, but time-space C, and met Xiaoyu C; time-space C was just before Xiaoyu discovered the "Secret" score, nothing had happened yet.
3. How to interpret the graduation photo?
The rule of traveling through time and space is that only the person who sees it at first sight can see you. The graduation photo shows that everyone in Time and Space C can see Xianglun A; the explanation is that the piano used as the medium of time and space is destroyed, and Ye Xianglun cannot go back; Time and Space A's Xianglun A stayed in time and space C forever, and the rules became invalid.
4. Why did Ye Xianglun go to the third time and space?
Lu Xiaoyu B of Time and Space B successfully came to Time and Space A every time, why did Ye Xianglun of Time and Space A be out of place in time and space?
The original soundtrack CD of "The Unspeakable Secret" has two versions of the "Secret" piano music, one is the normal version of Lu Xiaoyu, and the other is the accelerated version of Ye Xianglun. Ye Xianglun was in an urgent situation, so the accelerated version of "Secret" popped up and returned to the earlier time and space C.
5. How to change history?
Everyone should remember that part of Lu Xiaoyu Li Kebai, especially the first time I watched a horror movie; suddenly words appeared on the desktop.
Primary articles mentioned two different time consistency, so things done at an earlier time, the future will change the history of
why this movie is the final outcome is: A space-time Xianglun A back earlier than the time and space B The time and space C of time and space changed all the history of time and space B and A.
Advanced articles: hidden secrets
do you think movies are all the secrets you know? Do you really understand "The Secret That Cannot Be Told"?
One, three times and three light rains.
Xiaoyu B of Time and Space B is dead, Xiaoyu C of Time and Space C and Xianglun A live happily together; Where is Xiaoyu of Time and Space A?
You might say that Xiaoyu B in Time and Space B is dead, and where is Xiao Yu A in Time and Space A?
Think about the words Xiaoyu engraved on the table. There was no such thing, but it suddenly appeared because of the change of Xiaoyu B in Space-Time B.
Assuming that there was no misunderstanding, Xiaoyu B would not be stimulated and die from an asthma attack;
Space-Time A's table has no words before Xiaoyu B in Time and Space B has no words.
Similarly , before Xiao Yu B in Time and Space B has died, Xiao Yu in Time and Space A has not died either!
Second, the rain 99 years of existence proved time and space A, 99 years drizzle mother is not crazy
at this time rain should be about four-year-old middle-aged.
The first time Xiaoyu B took Xianglun A to the roof of her house, before going upstairs, a middle-aged woman was photographed watching Ye Xianglun go up the roof (she also couldn't see Xiaoyu B). That person was not Xiaoyu’s mother. It is the middle-aged Xiao Yu A.
The second time Xiaoyu B did not go to "class" for many days. Xianglun went to Xiaoyu's house to meet her mother and bought a lot of apples. Apple is for Xiaoyu of course, not for Xiaoyu who died of madness.
For the third time Xianglun went to Xiaoyu's house, Xiaoyu's mother said that Xiaoyu was resting, and then went into the house. At the same time, the camera cut to the second floor of Xiaoyu's house. Ye Xianglun's movements were consistent with those of Xiaoyu's mother when she first entered. The person watching on the second floor was not. Xiao Yu's mother, but middle-aged Xiao Yu A.
The fourth time Xianglun went to Xiaoyu's house, it was also the first time to go in; it was also after discovering that Xiaoyu had disappeared, and it was also the time when Xiaoyu discovered the bracelet on Qingyi on Xianglun's hand and died of excessive illness and grief.
Xiao Yu’s mother asked Xianglun to enter the house, saying that Xiaoyu would listen to songs in the house. Indeed, Xiaoyu A listened to songs in the house, but the corresponding Xiaoyu B died before Xianglun entered the house twenty years ago. Time and space A. The history of was changed because of the changes in time and space B. At the same time, Xianglun discovered Xiaoyu’s hand-painted portrait of Xianglun. At the same time, Xiaoyu’s mother cried and said, "Mom should believe in Xiaoyu." At this time, Xiaoyu’s mother was also changed by history. Think Xiao Yu is dead.
Before, Xiao Yu’s mother had always said that Xiao Yu was there, which was not crazy; indeed, Xiao Yu A had existed before.
Third, resolve the outcome of
time and space A Yexiang Lun's father lost his son, maybe he did not punish the conservative rain secret of it, considered a tragedy;
time and space B road drizzle mother lost her daughter, because her daughter look at a "secret" The piano score is considered a tragedy;
the Lu Xiaoyu of Space-Time B is not believed by everyone, even being teased, tortured, and dying with endless sorrow, it is considered a tragedy;
Space-Time A and Ye Xianglun want to find a way to love him in Space-Time B Xiao Yu B, but there is no way to see you again, it becomes an eternal tragedy;
Dayong believes in Xiao Yu and is stunned by others, and Qingyi mistakenly falls in love with Ye Xianglun but to no avail. It is a tragedy...
Finally, Time and Space A's Xianglun A went to Time and Space C, changed all the history of Time and Space B and Time and Space A, prevented all tragedies from happening, and became the perfect ending, which can be regarded as a more dramatic ending. (This is also the ending that the audience want to see)
Fourth, boring dead end
Some would say 79 years Taiwan can not stand it white? The proof is there, but there is indeed no shortage in the mainland.
Some people would say that Ye Xianglun went back to the past to change all history. Isn't that there are two selves? God will arrange another person to be Huang Qiusheng's son.
Dayong is not being beaten stupid, is it...
Everyone should be back to reality, this is just a movie.
Fifth, the film's central idea of
what has happened in the real world there is no way to change history, in fact, meant to express Jay this movie is:
cherish the best of everything, including love and affection.
Friends who have fully understood all the secrets, please keep the secrets to friends who have never watched this film, and let them have the right to find these "Secrets That Cannot Be Said" on their own
View more about Secret reviews
