the hidden truth

Jeremie 2022-01-28 08:20:47

The director clearly glorified the perpetrator.
In order to increase the impact of the film, a lot of plots have been deleted. Is it also a contemptible hypocrisy to fabricate the so-called "truth of human nature" and the so-called "reasonable evil" for oneself?

According to Wikipedia's actual records, this Gertrude was a sadist who was poor, had no self-respect, and had a messed up life. Her abuse is open and dignified, and she will never falsely use the name of "education". In the end, she and her family even prepared to throw Sylvia's body... Sylvia tried to escape after overhearing, and was tortured to death. The so-called upper beam is not right and the lower beam is crooked. The children raised by Gertrude are used to this kind of abuse scene since childhood. How can they be so scared that their eyes are watery like in the film? On the contrary, the pleasure of sadism makes them very useful.
Such a woman is poor, neurotic, sluggish, and her life is a mess... Someone dares to entrust her beloved daughter to her! ...Parents, oversight so far!
Also, Wikipedia mentions that Sylvia's sister asked their own sister for help, and her own sister made up a lie that they thought they just wanted to live with her. In the film, Sylvia never ran away. Her sister was intimidated by a few words that were unrealistic at first glance. Is there a person as mentally retarded as fifteen or sixteen?

Therefore, why do you need to whitewash the peace, the truth is so simple: the American family is weak! Relatives are like passers-by, passers-by are not people!

View more about An American Crime reviews

Extended Reading
  • Leif 2022-03-28 09:01:13

    The reality is so unspeakable. There is a strong contrast between the beauty of the first half and the obscurity of the second half, from leisurely to crying. I think the Chinese people will be amazed after watching it. The human world in the movie is so indifferent. Adults (not to mention children) are like every brain. Into a tone particle: eh.

  • Clay 2022-01-28 08:20:47

    The event itself is extremely shocking. Catherine Keener's performance is really wonderful, but the narrative angle is very gentle. The display of the evil of human nature is weak, and it does not mention the impact on legislation.

An American Crime quotes

  • Gertrude Baniszewski: [preparing to write the tattoo onto Sylvia's belly] Ricky... she came back from juvenile! Started stirring up trouble again... Johnny hold her!

    Sylvia Likens: No, please, please!

    Gertrude Baniszewski: Keep her still!

    Marie Baniszewski: If you move, it'll only be messy.

    Gertrude Baniszewski: [gives Marie a lighter and a safety pin] Light that.

    Sylvia Likens: No! No! No! Please! No! No! Please! Please!

    Gertrude Baniszewski: Stop it!

    Shirley Baniszewski: You got it right, mama?

    Gertrude Baniszewski: Make sure it's hot!

    Sylvia Likens: I'm sorry! I'm sorry!

    Gertrude Baniszewski: You liar!

    Sylvia Likens: Please stop, please no! Please!

    [Marie gives Gertrude the safety pin]

    Gertrude Baniszewski: You branded my daughters... now I have to brand you.

  • Gertrude Baniszewski: Who's in charge here?

    Johnny Baniszewski: You are, mama.