fog of war notes

Shannon 2022-03-20 08:01:25

McNamara served as president of Ford Motor, Secretary of Defense for two U.S. presidents, and president of the World Bank. He was also the chief decision-maker and executor of the Vietnam War. The Harvard background makes him better at analyzing causes and adjusting strategies from outcome data. He speaks bluntly about the harm that the war has done to civilians and admits that his position has resulted in a large number of civilian deaths.

The documentary summarizes McNamara’s eleven lessons: 1. Understand the

enemy with empathy

2. Reason can’t save mankind 3.

People can’t just look at themselves All may mean huge casualties and destruction . In large-scale wars, human life becomes increasingly small. 5. Wars should follow the principle of proportionality. Go to war for the sake of conscience or interests, and the result is only winning or losing . 6. Obtaining information McNamara is good at looking at the reasons from the results, analyzing the data, and then adjusting and improving to affect the results. When he was president of a non-Ford family during the decline of the car Ford, he studied Ford's customer market, launched economical cars, analyzed the causes of car accidents, developed seat belts, and safer steering wheels. 7. Beliefs and seeing with one's own eyes are often wrong thoughts that lead to actions. If the thoughts are wrong, people only see what they want to see, and what they see is not necessarily true. 8. Review your thoughts at any time 9. Sometimes evil must be done for good . War is cruel, so is it justified by evil and killing? 10. There is no absolute thing in the world 11. Human nature cannot be changed. He proposed "the fog of war, war is too complicated, human beings cannot use their brains to understand all the variables, our judgment and understanding are not enough, so it will kill People who deserve to be killed" have limits to rationality. "We can't stop exploring, the end of our exploration will return to the starting point,



































Rediscover this place. "

He doesn't say a word about responsibility and guilt for the war.

View more about The Fog of War reviews

Extended Reading
  • Lane 2022-03-20 08:01:25

    At least he is qualified to take these eleven classes. At least he is sincere. Moore's film is like a squeaking clown in front of this film.

  • Gracie 2022-03-26 09:01:14

    The eleventh admonition in "The Fog of War" is "You cannot change human nature", as Errol Morris said: "It tells you that all other admonitions are worthless, that the human condition is indeed Hopeless.” Because to Errol Morris, all kinds of people are parochial, self-deceiving, self-serving, like “a bunch of gorillas running around.”

The Fog of War quotes

  • Robert McNamara: It's almost impossible for our people today to put themselves back into that period

    [the Cold War]

    Robert McNamara: . In my seven years as Secretary, we came within a hair's breadth of war with the Soviet Union on three different occasions! Twenty-four hours a day, three-hundred sixty-five days a year, for seven years as Secretary of Defense, I lived the Cold War! During the Kennedy Administration, they designed a one-hundred Megaton bomb! It was tested in the atmosphere; I remember this.

  • Robert McNamara: [referring to auto accident research at Cornell Aeronautical Lab] They said "the main problem is packaging." They said "you buy eggs and you know how eggs come in a carton?"

    [...]

    Robert McNamara: So Cornell said "they don't break because they're packaged properly. Now if we package people in cars the same way, we could reduce the breakage."