are ranting

Alta 2022-03-13 08:01:01

Isaburo and his son Yugoro in "The Sword of Death" are stubborn and disobey the lord's orders. Is it the honor of the samurai? Family honor?

As a samurai, obedience to the boss is a duty, and the lord can find any reason to order samurai to cut his belly. Isaburo's refusal not only has nothing to do with the samurai's honor, but is contrary to the samurai's honor. At the same time, judging from the Sasahara family's pressure on Isaburo, Isaburo's obedience to the order will not damage the family's honor.

So what was the reason for Isaburo's refusal? The movie has repeatedly pointed to the theme of the happiness of the marriage with Goro and Ashi. Such a beautiful relationship cannot be trampled at will. Reasons such as the beauty of feelings were completely insignificant in the pre-modern era. In that society that talked about disciples, rank, rules and etiquette, personal feelings were simply not mentioned on the table. The prevailing attitude of the samurai era was that of Isaburo's wife, but Isaburo was against the trend.

It's not so much a samurai movie as it's an anti-samurai movie with a modern twist. Isaburo did not hesitate to burn all the jade and stone, precisely to maintain the values ​​he valued, not the obedience of the ignorant samurai.

It is a modern concept that people fight for personal beliefs and values, while pre-modernism emphasizes that people fight for honor, because the so-called honor is defined by the mainstream social values ​​and dominated by public opinion.

View more about Samurai Rebellion reviews

Extended Reading
  • Antwon 2022-03-20 09:03:07

    8/10. The peak of the movie context should be like this: suspenseful and calm, mysterious and unpredictable, skilled and refined, strong and tragic! The disadvantage is that the first 3/4 of the foreshadowing does too much nonsense, which leads to the boring atmosphere no matter how good the atmosphere is. The design of light and shadow, the scheduling settings of camera angles, and a lot of inner metaphors are not inferior to the exquisiteness of "Cut the Belly".

  • Lexie 2022-03-25 09:01:23

    Not only "Scholars can be killed, but not insulted", but more importantly, they are talking about the real "Tao". To tame someone or a certain family is not the true way, nor is it to be tame to duty. The "Tao" to be guarded should be basic human nature, a person's absolute loyalty to one's own heart. You can say this is selfishness, but sacrificing oneself in fear of that stronger selfishness is also not selflessness, but a betrayal of sincerity. In fact, this is not a tragedy. In fact, it is extremely rare to meet three people who understand the "Tao" and do not compromise on death. For the father who gave in and compromised his whole life in the film, he can only truly live if it ended like this.

Samurai Rebellion quotes

  • Isaburo Sasahara: Each must live his own life.

  • Isaburo Sasahara: Seppuku? Ho ho!