Criticism about the film (immature view)

Haskell 2022-03-22 09:02:50

The short comments of the film critics are short and terrifying, most of them are written on the Chinese revolution and wonderful short sentences, but the words are few, the depth is also small, and the content is not broad. The comments in the film may be limited by the vision of contemporary young people. The film's interpretation of the symbols of Bakunin's writings, the historical disputes between the United States and Mexico in the West, the revolution and the western cowboys, the interpretation of postmodernism, etc. have not been discussed in detail. The director used Western culture and capitalist theory to create the film, or would it be better to read Western comments?

View more about Duck, You Sucker! reviews

Extended Reading
  • Ole 2022-03-14 14:12:30

    (8/10) A revolution is not a dinner party. A revolution is a riot of one class to overthrow another - Emperor Mao Wu. James Cobain, who appeared later, is the protagonist of the story, and I mostly watched this film for Cobain. Revolutions are always people who shouted the slogan of equality to replace the previous dynasty, and then do the same thing as the previous dynasty, and don't think about the economy and stability until everyone is bleeding and tired. History has never been an exception.

  • Destinee 2022-03-26 09:01:13

    The score is artificially high, and it feels like Leone is playing off. There are more and more facial close-ups, and the music has no grand and atmospheric momentum. Compared with the revolutionary past, it is more appropriate to call it an Oolong hero. The whole movie is well said in that sentence, that revolution cannot be achieved through humility and grace.

Duck, You Sucker! quotes

  • Juan Miranda: What kinda work you do for the German? Listen, I asked you a question. What do you do for the German?

    John H. Mallory: I've been looking for silver.

    Juan Miranda: Silver? You know something? I don't understand you. I don't understand how you waste your time and your holy water looking for silver. To me, that's a sin.

    John H. Mallory: Do you have any better ideas?

    Juan Miranda: Si, I think gold is better than silver.

    John H. Mallory: Ah, there isn't any gold in these hills.

    Juan Miranda: Oh ho, yes there is! In Mesa Verde.

    John H. Mallory: Mesa Verde? It's a city.

    Juan Miranda: Of course it's a city! Who ever heard of having a bank in the country, huh?

    John H. Mallory: Uh huh. A bank?

    Juan Miranda: Not "a bank." *The bank!* The most beautiful, wonderful, fantastic, gorgeous, magnificent bank in the whole world! When you stand before the bank and you see it has the gates of gold, like it was the gates of heaven. And when you go inside, everything, *everything* is gold! Gold spittoons, gold handles, and money, money, money is everywhere. And you know, I know 'cause I saw this when I was eight years old. I went there with my father. He tried to rob the bank, but they caught him. But they will never catch me, eh, Papa?

    Papa Miranda: Right.

    Juan Miranda: Listen, Firecracker. Now you listen to me... listen, why don't you come with me, eh? And we will work together... and we will become rich.

    [chuckles]

    Juan Miranda: What the hell is your name?

    John H. Mallory: [wearily] Seán...

    Juan Miranda: What?

    John H. Mallory: John.

    Juan Miranda: What is your name?

    John H. Mallory: John.

    Juan Miranda: [laughs] That's fantastic, that is incredible, eh! My name is Juan and yours is John! It's Juan and John, eh? Heh, heh!

    John H. Mallory: So what?

    Juan Miranda: What do you mean, "So what?" Can't you understand that is... that is... the... oh... ah... destiny.

    [John remembers his girlfriend and friend]

  • Juan Miranda: Hey, what kind of trouble you in?

    John H. Mallory: Oh, we had a wee fart of a revolution in Ireland.

    Juan Miranda: A revolution? Seems to me the revolutions are all over the world. You know, they're like the *crabs*! We had a revolution here. When it started, all the brave people went in it, and what it did to them was terrible. Pancho Villa, the best bandit chief in the world, you know that? This man had two balls like the bull. He went in the revolution as a great bandit. When he came out, he came out as what? Nothing. A general, huh? That, to me, is the bullshit!