Let’s talk about the original book first. In fact, I almost forgot the details of the original book. I just remember that I was shocked after reading the book, and then there were more than a dozen grandma’s books in the bookcase at home. After reading the comments and discussion forums for a long time, I finally understood the differences between the original and this version. Let me tell you what I think can be improved: the
modus operandi can actually be shown. To be honest, many people really know what the following plot is with their eyes closed when they watch this show. It can be shown without revealing the suspect. The method of killing, so that the final killing method is still cloudy and foggy. You can even mislead the audience with the details of the murder technique, which is one of the bad tastes of mystery novels.
I don't quite understand why the first person died when it was not revealed on the spot. It's a bit unreasonable that no one has questioned after drinking and choking to death, and if the first person is murdered, the overall atmosphere can be better promoted.
In my opinion, the police's death method is not good. After all, the age difference and physical strength between the two of them are poor. In terms of the murderer's personal strength, it should be that the organization is far better than the hand-to-hand combat, and the risk is smaller.
The final explanation can't be said to be bad, but I still feel a little regretful. It may be to further describe the personality characteristics of the murderer and the heroine. Although I think other words and pictures can also achieve the goal, but the director and screenwriter want to come. Come on. . .
It is not impossible for a doctor to form an alliance with a judge, but it feels more reasonable that the judge must make a suggestion first. As a master of controlling psychological suggestion, there is obviously something that can be done here. After all, the doctor is the person who is most likely to be psychologically suggested after the heroine.
Although there are some deficiencies, I still think it is worth watching, after all, the British sound. . . Ahem, after all, the BBC conscience drama shows the British customs, social structure and contradictions in the 1930s very well. If you look down on the big, you can see some shadows of the past in all aspects of the upper and lower classes. And in order to pay tribute to grandma, this point must be praised. In addition, the muscle handsome guy or something is also worth watching~~~ Hide it~~~
and then say a little digression, anyway, it is estimated that not many people will see this movie review, haha.
Just now, I saw a comment in the short comment section saying that I didn't like this last change, saying that the original book is more inclined to exercise justice, rather than the judge's personal hobby and personality. I don't remember what the original book stood out. But last year, I also thought about a lot of things like this because of some things, and then I came up with a sentence, all the judges, please tap: the minority is the truth, and the majority is justice. But it does not mean that the two are opposites, but that the former lies in detection and the latter in judgment. The minority seeks out the original appearance of things, while the majority enforces the right to judge. After all, it is obvious in Grandma's drama. The murder case on the Orient Express is the most typical example.
Why do you mention this, because if it's just for personal opinion, I give full marks to this game, and if you say it's for the enforcement of justice, I give zero marks. Justice doesn't give anyone the right to lynch, no matter the circumstances, because if you're lynching then you're essentially no different from those murderers. This is reflected in many Western literature and film and television dramas, and even the popular American comics, among which the master is the most prominent person. After blowing the west side, let’s talk about the Celestial Dynasty. The system, ideology and culture of the Celestial Dynasty are different in all aspects, so the literary works produced are quite different. The most typical ones are martial arts novels, from the earliest legends of the Tang Dynasty, to the later Song and Yuan Dynasties, and later Ming and Qing Dynasties. Martial arts novels, as well as modern novels such as Jin Gu, although the children of the rivers and lakes have grievances and hatreds, in fact, the real heroes rarely use martial arts to commit crimes, and even rob the rich and help the poor. Instead of replacing the judiciary with an individual, Jin Yongjing's idea that the great man should serve the country and the people has taken it to a higher level. Okay, let’s talk nonsense here, you don’t need to pay attention to me~~~
Finally, a few refutations, many people say why these ten people don’t form a group, it’s unscientific, and why the heroine suddenly ran away and has been hinted that the guidance is unscientific, blabla, to put it bluntly, the plot of a literary work is needed, but the foreshadowing is unreasonable. It is a novel that changes according to reality. He also has a lot of things that must be changed and become unscientific. Otherwise, it would be good for everyone to write running accounts. ? In fact, this is also very similar to a killing game. You can't question the rules of the game, saying that I am a civilian, and I will not close my eyes at night, or if there are werewolves together, we will never be alone. Have fun!
Well, I wrote so much, it is pure nonsense, all kinds of patting bricks are welcome.
View more about And Then There Were None reviews
