-
Ruthe 2022-03-22 09:02:51
Lara grew up like Saoirse, aunt Clarissa like Julie Delpy with orange...
-
Jackson 2022-03-22 09:02:51
Subtle relationships work wonderfully. Good things go right everywhere, just like...
-
Bridie 2022-03-22 09:02:51
Originally thought that the child is the one who is deaf and the one who needs to be taken care of, but it turned out to be the opposite - I was afraid of losing you; it was refreshing. I always feel that two people who communicate in sign language can get very close no matter what, the romance of "i will survive" is broken. Sign language is so beautiful. (PS: Isn't that the heroine... She speaks German so...
-
Delmer 2022-03-22 09:02:51
Simple stories, delicate feelings, and the things around them are always easy to...
-
Agnes 2022-03-22 09:02:51
The story of music and family love is so heartwarming, delicate and restrained, and all the feelings are just right to the point. If the same theme is put into the Celestial Dynasty, I believe that the director must not let the audience sway the audience so much that he will not give...
-
Clare 2022-03-22 09:02:51
Both parents are good-looking, but the little girl's voice becomes scary when she grows up, and she looks good... The plot is still good, the love part is extremely redundant... The German subtitles in class seem to be...
-
Otto 2022-03-22 09:02:51
Look at the song played by the heroine of the original soundtrack called love...
-
Lenna 2022-03-22 09:02:51
"The truth is already in your heart, listen to the tune of your...
-
Tess 2022-03-22 09:02:51
Listening and understanding are...
-
Rebeca 2022-03-22 09:02:51
The little girl is constantly tossing between her deaf parents and her aunt who is a musician, and finally her dreams and family relationships are finally reconciled. The script is actually quite weak, and the more the protagonist grows up, the less likable it becomes. But the scene where the aunt dances on the glacier in the opening scene is so...
Beyond Silence Comments
-
Afton 2022-02-07 14:51:20
silence
I've read the movie a few years ago, and I haven't seen any reviews, so no one recommends it. Movies about music will subconsciously want to watch. After a few years, why, oh, why do I always ask myself so many whys.
The same lonely night, the same silent space. A somewhat rebellious little girl,... -
Arnold 2022-02-07 14:51:20
Silent world, do we understand?
When I was watching the movie, I thought, walking out of the silence may mean Lara walking out of the silent home, but maybe it also means opening up people's hearts. Because the subtitles are in English, there may be some omissions, but I probably still understand. This movie, this whole process,...
-
Lara: The saddest things in life are separations and deaths. I don't want to say good-bye anymore. I've had enough of that.
-
Martin: How does snow sound? What does it say to you?
Lara: It says, "Crunch, crunch, brr, brr."
Martin: What are "crunch" and "brr"? What kind of words are they?
Lara: To tell the truth, snow doesn't say much. It's even said that snow swallows every sound. When snow is on the ground, everything is much quieter.
Martin: Honest? Snow makes the world quiet? That's beautiful.
Director: Caroline Link
Language: German,German Sign Language,English,Spanish Release date: June 5, 1998