The Joy Luck Club Comments

Johann 2022-03-23 09:03:04

Losing him does not matter. It is you who will be found and cherished. PS: For two days, I watched the same actor play the same kind of boy/man. (I watched it once at home when I was a child, my grandma said it was a good...

Eileen 2022-03-23 09:03:04

The idea is great, showing the hardships of women's awakening in different cultural backgrounds. But the shortcomings are also obvious. There are too many materials, and everyone's story is too dramatic, but the film capacity is limited, which eventually leads to the plot being too rushed, the lines are blunt, and there is a lack of more details to fill the role. About Chinese-American films, I prefer "Face". PS I watched this film to admire Yu Feihong's beauty, but I drooled at Tommy Tan...

Roberta 2022-03-22 09:02:40

Regarding the emotional epic of women, four groups of mother-daughter relationships in two time and space, the conflict of values ​​between China and the West, and the generation gap between the two generations are all explained by Wang...

Carroll 2022-03-21 09:03:01

For the characterization of the four stories, the supporting characters of each story and the objective factors of the protagonist are ignored. Although the four stories are well told, they are slightly superficial. But this is still a good film. The director is Chinese after all, and he expresses the delicate and sincere emotions in Chinese culture very well. In addition, when using the four mother-daughter stories in the whole film to extend to the thinking level of Chinese and Western...

Linwood 2022-03-20 09:02:37

I think there is a gap, maybe Americans or Chinese Americans can really understand this piece. The person who recommended me to watch before said that this film can be compared with Lee Ang's "Pushing Hands" and "Diet Men and Women". How could it be possible? The difference is too far. Ang Lee is...

Dora 2022-03-20 09:02:37

At first it felt okay. As a result, the more I looked at the back, I realized that this was a formulaic and symbolic film, bearing the stigma of a film that was made in that era of cultural differences between China and the West. Both the language and the costumes were shot to cater to the Americans. The traditional Chinese values ​​and resentment conveyed in it make people feel uncomfortable. Because I watched Shield, I looked back on Wen Mingna's previous movies, and I also saw Zhou Caiqin....

Josie 2022-03-20 09:02:37

"All of us are like stairs, one step after another, going up and down, but all going the same way." "Everytime u hoped for something I couldn't deliver, it hurt. It hurt me, Mommy. And no matter what u hope for, I'll never be more than what I am. And u never see that, what I really...

Fanny 2022-03-20 09:02:37

Mother never expects how much reward her daughter’s life will bring. Mother just hopes that her daughter will be happy and that her life will be different from her. She is always anxious to sum up all her injuries into experience. Let the daughter keep in mind, but the daughter seemed uncooperative or disgusted with this kind of "manipulation" at the time.. Oh, because the daughter is always like a mother, even if she grew up in a different cultural background of the...

Raphaelle 2022-03-19 09:01:08

Compared with the Snow Secret Fan, this film nearly 20 years ago is even more commendable. With a huge structure, the stories of the four pairs of mother and daughter can be said to be a portrayal of the status of women in the relationship between relatives in the old society, but they are also different. Maybe the relationship between my mother and daughter is easier to move me! It’s just that the finishing touch is a bit weak, and I’ve been looking forward to the best ending. . . (Brother...

Demarco 2022-03-19 09:01:08

Multi-threaded narrative and multiple structures are the strengths of Westerners. Wang Ying is obviously not good at this. The unfolding of each story uses the same technique, which is too monotonous. Too many stories will weaken the details and hinder each other, even with the same theme; the shots are still great, Wang Ying especially likes to use close-up shots and close-ups, which puts high demands on...