Human nature is indistinguishable between good and evil

Miller 2022-04-21 09:02:51

It is Hirokazu Koreeda, who, in my opinion, has been insisting on doing one thing, exploring whether human nature is good or evil. From "Nobody Knows" in 2004, "Like Father Like Son" in 2013, to "The Third Suspect" in 2017, and now "The Thief Family" in 2018, they are all talking about this issue. In 2013 "Like Father Like Son", Nonomiya Rakuten learns how to get along with children without blood relationship. This time, Shibata Haru, played by Lily Franky, and Shibata Nobuyoshi, played by Ando Sakura, shouldered the above tasks and worked hard to learn to be a child who loves and is loved by children (the metaphor of whether children call themselves father or mother). parent" role. Aiming at legal gray areas, such as comparing the evil deeds committed by the legal good (Yuri's parents' abuse of their daughter) with the good deeds of the legal bad (the Shibata couple's sheltering of abused children), It is a continuation of the "Third Degree Suspect" (2017), where Sanyu is recognized as a murderer who is full of evil, and it is difficult to distinguish the good from the bad.

So it is said that Hirokazu Kore-eda has not changed at all. If it is said that he has changed, it means that he is more cruel and questioning the meaning and value of life more deeply. Many people gave "The Third Suspect" bad reviews, and the director also said: "I'm sorry, this film did not give everyone the answer." Because there is no answer at all in human nature and rules! You didn't understand it was Hirokazu-eda before. This time he gave the result, a very cruel answer. I would like to continue to talk about the works of the film master Kubrick, "A Clockwork Orange" and "2001: A Space Odyssey", which I paid tribute to. Kubrick used images many years ago to discuss issues in human nature, such as violence, Lust, fear, etc. I will never forget the title of "A Clockwork Orange", like which colors: red, green, blue, purple, etc. People are made up of many colors. What color should violence be? red? Kubrick gives the answer in the movie. Jiang Wen used a large piece of red in the title of "The Evil Does Not Overpower the Righteous", which also made me excited.

View more about Shoplifters reviews

Extended Reading
  • Monserrat 2022-03-25 09:01:14

    No tears scenes. Of course, I also highly agree that it is Hirokazu Koreeda's brilliant technique of refining "human nature", as well as the sense of time and space that "gets to the point" that gets more and more obscured. But I must also admit that, for some reason, I personally have never been able to empathize in any of his works, and it seems that with age, the ability to empathize becomes weaker. So the more I envy the friends around me who can blend in and enjoy the universe. Going back to the thief, I think it is brilliant that this is not the gentle and hazy beauty of the East, but a vague area of ​​emotional morality for all human beings. After pulling away from the history of strangers' combination as home, the daily life of each other is rather emotional.

  • Robb 2022-03-26 09:01:09

    The betrayal and injury of the original family, the consolation and fetters of meeting by chance, cannot be chosen by blood, and the little bit of light that they choose to run towards, which is almost hopeful, may bring about the illusion of happiness, but after all, it is false and cannot bring come to the rescue. The disintegration and reorganization of the home, the pain and struggle at the bottom of the quagmire are the culmination of Hirokazu Koreeda's theme and elements, so warm, yet so cruel and desperate.

Shoplifters quotes

  • Hatsue Shibata: I was sure she'd want to go home.

    Nobuyo Shibata: Do you think she... chose us?

    Hatsue Shibata: Usually you can't choose your own parents.

    Nobuyo Shibata: But then, maybe it's stronger when you choose them yourself.

    Hatsue Shibata: What is?

    Nobuyo Shibata: What is...

    [pause]

    Nobuyo Shibata: The bond. The bond.

    [pause]

    Hatsue Shibata: I chose you, too.

  • Osamu Shibata: [to Yuri after seeing television reports of Yuri's disappearance] Do you think you can make it home by yourself?