A great movie, but it has its flaws

Darrion 2022-04-20 09:01:47

This is a movie that is admired by almost all the audience (including those who are professional filmmakers) who have seen him. Because it is the first time that the so-called "movie montage theory" has been carried forward in practice.
But here, I still want to "risk the world" and talk about the inadequacies of this movie.
Soviet films (including those in the former Soviet Union) were more or less a matter of form rather than content. The great Eisenstein was actually not exempt.
This is most evident in the passage of "Odessa Stairs", in which Eisenstein almost "crazy" shows a "cross montage" shot, which obviously makes the passage itself seem a bit "" The narrative logic" is messed up. (For example: what happened to the cradle that didn’t stop falling?)
In fact, I prefer the last paragraph in the film. The navy soldiers who were sent by the Russian government to suppress the people ended up dramatically falling into the arms of the people. . Compared with "Odessa Stairs", this sequence is quite simple and direct, but it is full of strong artistic and emotional appeal.
This is the perfect combination of technology and content!

View more about Battleship Potemkin reviews

Extended Reading
  • Raleigh 2022-03-28 09:01:04

    In addition to the editing, the music is also excellent, and the emotional crowd after the sailor was killed really made the blood boil. The film itself is a myth, and at the same time an industrial product. The cheering crowd amazed that the film industry in the 1920s had such a powerful ability to mobilize. The film not only revealed the spirit of the Soviet Union, but also demonstrated the organizational power and control power of the new system that is no weaker than the capitalist society, heralding a new era. paradox.

  • Viva 2022-03-26 09:01:07

    Too much information to suppress a single lens. In addition to a few classic clips, there are some interesting passages. For example, the officer fell into the water, took the lifebuoy shot, and took the uprising panorama with the lifebuoy.

Battleship Potemkin quotes

  • Chief Officer Giliarovsky: The sailors refused to eat the borscht.

  • Commander Golikov: Whoever is satisfied with the borscht take two steps forward!