Ambivalent interpretation

Buster 2022-04-23 07:03:41

The story Cries and Whispers is narrated by a feminist perspective.

"Mother" in this film is unconcerned and reckless, unless she and her daughter share the sadness. It's like a default and mutual communication without words, but it's unplanned.

Female's desire in Bergman's films is not satisfied completely even sometimes beyond morality. Furthermore, they are undoubtedly still thirsty and desperate regardless of morality as usual via their undisguised eye contact, words and behavior.

Maria tries to be active and trying to take the initiative in the ambiguous relationship with the doctor, but she is judged by his values, and she judges herself by his values ​​about age, laziness and indifference. Then, she doubts and changes herself in a painful way in order to struggle for male's mercy. However, female is able to relieve and cure themselves by listening and comforting. More importantly, they always give priority to honesty towards males, life and themselves, which is more courageous and intelligent than males.

One potential explanation might be that this film is a sort of reflection of Bergman's personally growing experience.

Dissolution between different identifications.

Expressionist decor.

Should “female” be seen as a group or individuals?

View more about Cries & Whispers reviews

Extended Reading
  • Sam 2022-03-28 09:01:08

    8.5 points or so. Shouts and whispers, outbursts and softness, seemed to separate Maria from the other two sisters. Is Bergman still partial to Uman so that's why? No, no, there is also a woman in the film - Anna, and Morrow said that Bergman's preference has always been the "Anna" in his play. The taciturn maid is the only redemption in the family's tragic memory, as if the director hoped to use it to mend his own. So after everything fell apart, we saw the most beautiful scene: three young and kind sisters playing on a swing in the woods under the sun, the smiling maid gently rocked them for them. At that moment time seemed to stand still, if at that moment time stopped...

  • Francisco 2022-03-26 09:01:10

    This picture is too beautiful, even Caravaggio in several places. Interestingly, similar structures such as "Sick-Healthy People", closed spaces, and character wrestling appeared in "Still in the Mirror" in 1961, "Silence" in 1963, and "Masquerade" in 1966. appeared again. The subject of discussion is still the loss of communication and discourse, and there are still inescapable "Bergmanian propositions"—love and alienation for mothers, hatred for brothers, and what he calls "emotional blackmail," and his Tirelessly questioning God. Even the "Agnes Resurrection" scene in the details comes from his ten-year-old experience of being locked up in a morgue. The real Bergman I like exists in these four women, "I don't trust anyone, I don't love anyone, and I don't miss anyone", harsh, indifferent, and Anna is his secret room. The open gap is absolutely gentle. Like two sides of a coin, firmly attached to each other. (I love him 555)

Cries & Whispers quotes

  • Agnes: There's someone out there. Anna. There's someone out there.

  • Maria: Your arguments have always bored me.