The first battle was really inexplicable and meaningless.

Sunny 2022-04-21 09:03:04

This is the most different war documentary I have ever seen. First of all, the filming method is not narrated by historical experts, and there is no picture of the parties involved. It completely uses historical video materials, accompanied by the oral history of British veterans, and restores and colors the historical images. To the extent that it restores the mental journey of ordinary soldiers in the First World War from joining the army to the end of the war, it can be used as a great movie to watch as historical data.

The second is about thinking about war, from the perspective of ordinary soldiers standing on the front line, without the sermons of politicians and the summary and refinement of historians, there are only the most real feelings of ordinary soldiers, who can't understand the war. Meaning, especially in the process of getting along with the German prisoners, they are also mostly decent people, and like the British, their bodies are just controlled by the uniform.

As a famous director, Peter Jackson can make such a non-commercial film really admirable, because it is a strong complex in his heart, his grandfather is a veteran of World War I, this work is dedicated to him grandfather.

I hope that human beings will stay away from war forever. As an ordinary soldier on the front line, I really don’t know the meaning of war. At that time, there is only fear of fear and trust in comrades in arms, and there is absolutely no grand narrative and historical significance of politicians and historians.

View more about They Shall Not Grow Old reviews

Extended Reading
  • Leonie 2022-03-16 09:01:06

    Looking at the war from the perspective of a young soldier, it started inexplicably, and went to the front line honestly, with a romantic sense of heroism, then tortured trenches and bloody battlefields, and ended suddenly and inexplicably a few years later. Back then, people said that it was a war to end all wars, but in fact it was the beginning of modern warfare.

  • Alyson 2022-03-29 09:01:07

    Just these two days, I was thinking about the difference in expression between black and white and color images, and I completely understood the moment I saw the picture was converted from black and white to color. credit). I can't imagine how their loved ones felt when they were filmed but never returned home, seeing them "resurrected". Authenticity is always the most moving and precious, and on this level, the film can undoubtedly get full marks. But some of the technical handling made it difficult for me to fully immerse in it, and one of the most important points was the conflict between 3D effect and clarity. The strong sense of dizziness brought by the sense of space to the viewer without the support of clarity is too uncomfortable. If it is not clear, I would rather not use 3D.

Top cast

They Shall Not Grow Old quotes

  • Soldier: [waving at camera] Hi, mum.

  • Soldier: You don't look, you see. You don't hear, you listen. You taste the top of your mouth. Your nose is filled with fumes and death. But the veneer of civilization has dropped away.