Cruelty comes from reality

Selina 2022-01-20 08:01:28

Rossellini is worthy of being one of the three giants of Italian neorealism. After watching the movie in German Year Zero, it made me horrified but sighed.

What frightens me is the indelible harm that war has brought to children. Edmund is a special protagonist of children's movies. He is different from the carefree children in most movies. He is the pillar of the whole family. His childhood was full of tribulations. From the beginning to the end of the film, Edmund continued to endure various difficulties. He was dismissed from the work of digging the grave, watching the horse being driven away, the food at home was not enough, his father was sick in bed, and his brother was a fugitive from war. His life Full of all kinds of problems. As a child, he has no way to rely on and has to bear the pressure of supporting a faltering family.

At the same time, he has the direct, simple and innocent thinking that is unique to children, so he is willing to help teachers go to the black market to resell Hitler's tapes, and he is also willing to continue to follow the teacher's teachings. It was the paranoid misunderstanding of the teacher's words that led to the tragic ending of his killing his father and committing suicide.

Rossellini’s choice to start from the perspective of children is very clever. Every family has children, and the future of society is also a child. From the impact of war on a child, we can see the long-term impact of war on society as a whole and society in the future.

Edmund's tragic life, magnified to see, is the sorrow of the whole of Germany. Although Germany is the base of Nazi fascism, no matter whether it is a fascist country or an allied country, the wounds brought by the war to the people are the same.

View more about Germany Year Zero reviews

Extended Reading
  • Eveline 2022-03-27 09:01:19

    3.5. It feels like an exercise in Rossellini's transition to psychorealism, trying to take longer time-lapse, more fluid (anxiety?) camera movements, in a city of ruins (like a race against time, The quasi-news capture and reaction to reality comes to mind in "The Good Man of the Three Gorges", but no rocket launch), and captures a character who is more difficult to predict - a vulnerable child who can easily magnify any "scorching secret" into a negative energy black hole Mind - so does it have to be long? The Teacher: The Homosexuality-Nazi Link Stereotype. The church bells I heard when I walked alone at the end, the passers-by standing by, "Happy Lazaro". The social Darwinist ideology that the weak should die, the boy's "kindness" to help ease the burden on the family. The solo at the end is very good. It is the kind of good enough to write into the development node of film modernity (Antonioni below). It is full of irrational impulses, cannot be easily logicalized, and catches the audience by surprise and has a faint empathy. The last paragraph is particularly blurry. Did you deliberately use thick grains when shooting? Or is the original film bad?

  • Okey 2022-03-20 09:02:41

    8 points. It's such a heavy film. For the defeated country, in addition to material and physical losses, the longer lasting war is often a sense of mental loss. When everything that was originally defended, protected, and worshiped is lost, people always have to choose where to go. When the organ remembered, people stared at the ruined church, and that moment seemed to be eternal. . .

Germany Year Zero quotes

  • Herr Rademaker: Tell me the truth. What did you do with the money?

    Edmund: What money?

    Herr Rademaker: The money for the scale. Did you give it to your father?

    Edmund: I swear that's not true.

    Herr Rademaker: You're not going to cheat me, boy. I know you'll do anything for money. You got into my house ...

    Edmund: The housing superintendent sent us here.

    Herr Rademaker: Yes, and I have to put up with it. Your father is a pain, always complaining. Why doesn't he die and give us some peace?

  • Edmund: I have no work, and neither does Eva. My brother still won't report and get his card.

    Il maestro: I understand, but what can I do?

    Edmund: My father needs treatment. Can't you help me? What can I do?

    Il maestro: There's nothing you can do. Times are hard for everyone, worse for weak and old people. You've done all you can.

    Edmund: But what if he dies?

    Il maestro: If he dies, he dies. We all die sooner or later. Would you rather die yourself or let an old man live?