Realist works that are not masterpieces enough

Ruby 2022-11-16 01:03:11

For the section chief's film, he may have also come into contact with the Three Gorges good people. But even so, based on my limited reading experience, this film is not excellent. So obsessed with expressing this underlying gloomy reality, I have also seen discussions that the section chief is suspected of catering to European film festivals? Maybe they do like it, it's to their taste, it doesn't matter. The film itself needs diversity. As the author of the film, of course, you can make it according to your own ideas. I think the core of the problem is not that the story shows the underlying rivers and lakes of the plot, but the completion of the entire film, the second half of the rhythm and the explanation of the story are not clean enough, there is a sense of looseness. In other words, he is not good enough in the formal art of the film. Another question is, to what extent has this reality been excavated?

Seeing a comment saying that the size of China's 9.6 million square kilometers is beyond our imagination. To be honest, I don't think people in a developed coastal city can understand this kind of coal-like film. A white-collar worker who goes to work drinking Starbucks in a high-end office building in Pudong, Shanghai, fundamentally cannot understand this kind of rustic life with a sense of struggle at the bottom. China is a country where pre-modern, modern and post-modern coexist.

But how to narrow this gap as much as possible and create certain possibilities for understanding is what the section chief needs to think about. As a lens language, compared to literary language, film should naturally have the advantage of being easier to empathize with. When we read Tolstoy's works, we can also resonate and understand the noble nobles in his works, and we can be moved. Reading Liu Qing's entrepreneurial history can also be touched by his pragmatic and revolutionary passion. Great literature across eras and countries can do it, and there is no reason why great movies can't. In this regard, the section chief did not do enough.

View more about Ash Is Purest White reviews

Extended Reading
  • Halie 2022-01-24 08:07:16

    Before it was a change, a compromise, or a gentle and conservative work by Jia Zhangke, "The Children of the Rivers and Lakes" was first of all a film with excellent workmanship and almost no shortcomings. This kind of excellence is not only reflected in the sound design and processing that impressed me the most (such as the drumbeat of "A Man Who Strengthens", a gunshot on the streets of Datong), but also the emotions of the characters, which are really like ashes after a volcanic eruption. The temperature is constantly freezing and receding. There is nothing to blame for Zhao Tao's superb performance only in a few scenes such as escape on a motorcycle and a room in Fengjie Hotel. Like the national standard dance and cigar, "Jianghu" is naturally an imported product from popular things like Hong Kong-produced films. "Jianghu Children" is a popular tragicomedy of "men go wrong, women go wrong", but it is also on a factual level. Last, digested the hard work of the section chief for nearly ten years (standing on the shoulders of "Ren Xiaoyao" and "The Good Man in Three Gorges"). There is no way to go back to Datong, but it disappears at the end of the surveillance camera screen and is actually connected to other independent movies.

  • Jan 2022-03-19 09:01:09

    Before watching the film, I deliberately re-watched "Ren Xiaoyao" and "The Good Man in Three Gorges". I feel that in Jia Zhangke's movie world, there will always be things that resemble acquaintances, like unreliable memories, as if they are in the same world. The same group of people, with the changes of society, staged similar stories in the same era. The films directed by Jia Zhangke have never been of a highly dramatic genre, but the difference in "The Children of the Rivers and Lakes" is that it is relatively fragmented and melodramatic. It is not a short-film assemblage, but a linear narrative with a very large time span. There are not so many things that think about symbolic aesthetics, and it does not just stay at the level of sitcoms, but through the re-deconstruction of the previous works, the interest of the work is guaranteed. At the same time, it also makes the director's authoritarian things more systematic. I feel that Jia Zhangke has been filming the same story all his life, like many big directors, but this time you can see him at his current age, his observation of humanity and humanity, his understanding of women and men, and the change of people to carry the society. The great changes over the past ten years.

Ash Is Purest White quotes

  • Bin: I've left.

  • Qiao: Volcano ash is very pure, isn't it?

    Bin: Maybe.

    Bin: Anything that burns at high temperature is made pure.