About the war

Mozelle 2022-01-20 08:04:49

Nagasaki today has forgotten the pain.

So are we.

Facing the atomic bomb, the Japanese were in a very sad but contradictory state.

After the war, Japan's rapid economic development was largely due to the help of the United States.

In this movie, when facing so-called relatives from the United States, the attitudes of the family are divided with age. From the attitude of grandma not wanting to go to the United States, to the attitude that mom and dad kept praising the villa after they went to Hawaii, to the attitude that relatives worried that the United States knew that grandfather died in the atomic bomb, to the children's anger but still suppressed when they heard the news of the atomic bomb. Can't help but want to go to the United States.

The conversation between the children and grandma reminded her of her brother's story.

One of them is about the brother after elopement. The children went to see the burnt down hut, and what burned down is always there.

And the second story is about the eyes. The children's guesses were all wrong in the end. That eye was the light after the explosion in the sky on the day of the atomic explosion.

The film is full of symbols everywhere. These symbols are depressing and painful.

The arrival of American Clarke pushed the whole film to its climax.

Clark is here to apologize. Although the United States has never publicly apologized. He said sorry to grandma. This is also the director who used his words to apologize to all Japanese people.

"The Americans dropped the atomic bomb to end the war. The war has been over for 45 years. But don't they continue now! For the war, people do everything, and everyone will perish in the end." This is the grandmother's respect for the sons and daughters of the United States. What we said.

I can't help but think of what the teacher said to us. The Japanese never thought that they were defeated by us. They always thought that they were defeated by the Americans and American atomic bombs.

For the Japanese, the atomic bomb is a painful memory. For the Chinese, it ended the long war early.

The film uses the mouth of grandma to remind people not to forget the war, but it avoids the most fundamental cause of the war and the atomic bomb.

However, after the war of aggression ended, we did not usher in peace. It's a self-killing civil war. I often think that if you put aside the old sayings of oppression and exploitation aside from the nation, then every war is the cannibalism of mankind, and the war will never end, because killing is also one of the nature of mankind.

At the end of the film, after seeing my grandma running in the storm and the umbrella she held high, I still cried.

If there was a creator, would he regret creating such a greedy and ugly creature as humans? But would he be intolerable because of human beings' pursuit of beauty and peace?

In any case, this movie is like "Sometime in April", which I will not forget for a long time after watching it.

View more about Rhapsody in August reviews

Extended Reading
  • Curtis 2022-04-23 07:04:10

    Some people choose to remember and some choose to forget. The collective memory of war is always imprinted on a nation. The atomic bomb in Nagasaki was actually much more enjoyable than the Nanjing Massacre.

  • Julianne 2022-04-20 09:02:25

    The so-called anti-war in the movie, after removing the heavy depiction, is anti-war defeat no matter how you look at it. Akira Kurosawa skillfully used a spring and autumn brushwork, not mentioning why the atomic bomb fell, and used the old man and pain to highlight the wounds left behind. The identity of the defeated country has been reversed, the label of the country that initiated the war has been erased, and only the image of the pitiful wounded remains. It's hard to believe that Emperor Kurosawa, who once described in detail the dark parts of Japanese society, finally shot such a right-wing work that decorated Taiping in his later years. If you think about it from a different perspective, this is also in line with Kurosawa Akira's film context. From the early days, Kurosawa Akira has been using movies to restore the national spirit and character, winning foreign countries from his debut work "Zi Sanshiro" and going there after the Meiji Restoration. Inferiority, conforming to the trend of samurai after World War II, and shaping the worship of history; tough guy character in contemporary themes; finally, with the passage of time in the 1990s, this film abandoned the label of militarism. Another interesting contrast is that the attitude of confronting foreigners in "Tsu Sanshiro" has long been missing in this film, and the changes in the international situation have changed the content of the film.

Rhapsody in August quotes

  • Kane: I got old and so did this organ.

  • Kane: People do anything just to win war. Sooner or later it will destroy us all.