Honey, what time is it over there?

Lelah 2022-02-07 14:52:39

It was after 2 am, I watched Cai Mingliang's "What Time Is There Over You", a bit like a character in the play, who always stayed up late at night alone.

My favorite movie of Tsai Ming-liang is "A Cloud in the Sky". It's too shocking. Modern people's ability to love has been exploited, and they are exploited to the point of being unable to love the person they should love. Yet thirsty, thirsty for love. This film has found a carrier, a perfect combination of metaphor and noumenon. The other films, "The Hole" and "Long Live Love" are also good.

This "What Time Are You Over There" may be because I was rather sleepy when I watched it, so I felt it was too boring. Time, clocks, this carrier looks like the face-changing in Jin Ji-de's "Time", but it maintains its own style too much, and its visibility is worth discussing.


I think the theme is still consistent, modern people's desire for love. Desire for love because love is not available. Xiaokang had no choice but to take a female customer who went to France as the object of his fantasies, and set the clocks down to Paris time for her to establish a connection with her. As for the girl, she lives alone in a country where no English is spoken, with no one to communicate with, and it is even difficult to survive. A Hong Kong girl she meets by chance brings her a little comfort. After her father's death, her mother also fell into a state of unrequited love. She could only hope for the return of her father's soul, which made the family dim and became more and more nervous.

When love has nowhere to go, desire becomes a substitute. Finally, almost on the same night, Xiaokang stayed in the night street and finished venting against the street girl in the car. The mother reappeared in full costume and completed a masturbation to the portrait of her father, while Xiang Qi from Paris lay on the same bed as the Hong Kong girl and kissed tentatively.

However, after all, desire cannot replace love, so we see that the prostitute secretly took the box of Xiaokang's watch, and the sisterly love between Xiangqi and the Hong Kong girl did not develop, and she put on the old watch she bought from Xiaokang. , and left with luggage.

The ending of the film is very meaningful. Xiangqi is asleep on a bench in the park. The suitcase is first dragged away, and then thrown into the pool to slowly float down. An old man - Xiaokang's father (?) picked up the suitcase and then Slowly approach the Ferris wheel.

what time is it there? This is a story of this side and the other side. Only when you can't find love on this side will you entrust your love to the other side. The well-off is placed in Paris, and the mother is placed in the underworld. In fact, life on the other side is also very lonely. All people are alone, all people yearn for love, so why can't love come true?

Tsai Ming-liang, a movie, takes the trouble to state the same reality, but what is the answer?

View more about What Time Is It There? reviews

Extended Reading
  • Chad 2022-03-17 09:01:09

    I read it fourteen years ago... Now that I think about it, it's a lonely story. From Lang Xiong, who was unanswered at first, to Li Kangsheng, who dialed the bell, to the heroine, they were all lonely. Staring at each other on the subway platform, I have experienced it myself in Paris. The scene at the end of the Tuileries Garden is Cai Mingliang's last tenderness. Also, Ye Tong's charming and sexy femininity is really underestimated! ! !

  • Anais 2022-04-23 07:04:42

    It is my favorite Tsai Ming-liang. The design of the scenes and shots are almost the same as those of the two films I watched before. I probably realized Cai Mingliang's style. After the heroine went to Paris, it became very interesting. Two characters, one is in a different place, the language barrier leads to aphasia and loneliness, the other Being in my hometown, unable to communicate with others, also caused aphasia and loneliness, and there were many cross-cuts between the two. In the end, the setting of the magical reality was simply magical. When I was looking at the works of the students in our school before, one of the works left a deep impression on me, that is, a fixed camera shot of a person sitting and eating bread for ten minutes, and reading poetry in the last few minutes. Now I know this is what I learned. Department (Bi Gan, studying Poetry), it is better not to imitate this kind of student works.

What Time Is It There? quotes

  • Shiang-chyi: Come on. Sell me this one.

    Hsiao-kang: It'd be bad luck to own my watch.

    Shiang-chyi: Why?

    Hsiao-kang: Someone in my family just died. I'm in mourning. I can't sell it to you.

  • Hsiao-kang: So we have dinner at midnight now?

    Mother: What do you know? Can't we go along with your dad's time?