Our doubts need to be placed

Murray 2022-02-07 14:51:30

As soon as it opened, his father called out his mother's stupidity in front of 4-year-old Portnay, killed himself and injured her. At the same time make her swear to live well. This way, Portnay cannot accept the news of her mother's death.
Go to my aunt's house and live with my cousin. My aunt talked about the story of Jesus' resurrection in an attempt to make Little Portnay accept the fact of her mother's death smoothly, but she couldn't stand up to Portnay's heavy questioning, and finally gave such a blunt and flimsy factual advice as "Mom can't come back".
When she went to the boarding school, the "daughter of God" told her that as long as she became a daughter of God, she could talk to God, so she braved the so-called test. Finally, in the cemetery, Mom showed up. Mom said that it was too late to say goodbye to her, she was already dead and could not come back. Little Portnay said, let's hide together, maybe they won't find out. Mom said a few words, and finally comforted her to learn to be happy. So at the end of the film, she showed a firm smile and said to her father, "Mummy taught me to learn to be happy. At this point, Little Portnay finally got out of the shadow of her mother's death and accepted the fact that she had never been able to understand.
Analysed in this way, the film becomes symbolism. However, this is also the usual method of movies. Only movies that can expand the meaning can be regarded as good movies.

Even the most sensible person has a time. When our doubts can't find a way out, its corpse will rot and breed all kinds of germs, fragility, paranoia, collapse, escape... There is a saying that when you understand everything, you forgive everything. Although life or individuals are never obliged to explain for us, but living, tired, and groping forward, we will inevitably encounter all kinds of earthly annoyances that kill us halfway, they consume and divert our fighting spirit, energy and energy. Passion makes us struggle blindly like a trapped beast. When the trouble reaches the depths of our heart and lungs, the placement of doubts is our stimulant and sedative. This placement of doubts, in terms of the plot of the film itself, is to move God's faith and blood love with sincerity. So it doesn't have to be a "scientific way", it doesn't have to be a plausible explanation.
According to the movie, the image of Little Porternay reveals such an initial state, I don't understand anything, any external statement may shake and expand my doubts, I am tightly bound by doubts, unable to move (Little Portnay has no interest in participating in the games and conversations among her peers, she has retired from the life she should have, and is unable to extricate herself in doubt and sadness), what I need is an explanation that I can accept, I need an explanation. A gentle way to set aside doubts that are running around.
At this point, the meaning conveyed by the film can be expanded in all directions.

View more about Ponette reviews

Extended Reading
  • Donna 2022-02-07 14:51:30

    I appreciate Doillon's effort in writing the screenplay so that his mother's accident and other facts are indirectly told to the viewers. But not perfectly done. Too much irrelevant info that he should have lost during editing. Beautiful music.

  • Danielle 2022-03-15 09:01:10

    At first, I struggled for a long time on whether the ratio of the film should be 1.35:1 or 1.66:1. Finally, it was finally confirmed that this film, which was supposed to be 1.66:1, should have been cut to 1.35:1 when it was turned into a plate, so that when it came, there were many close-ups and shots, and it was not very good. Plot minimalism, played by this kid. How did the director train? We are not afraid of death, but we are afraid that after death we will never see each other again. The appearance of my mother was a bit unexpected, but it was finally possible to have a warm ending.

Ponette quotes

  • La Fille de l'Internet: You shouldn't be so sad.

    Ponette: Yes, I should.

    La Fille de l'Internet: Your mother was sad, too. She cried on her way to Heaven. God cried as He waited for her. When God was on earth as Jesus, He cried, too. But usually He was as joyful as a child.

    Ponette: It isn't joyful to be a child.

  • Ponette: I'm waiting for my mommy.

    Matiaz: Dead people don't come back.

    Ponette: Jesus did it for his friends. I'm more than a friend. I'm my mommy's daughter.

    Matiaz: Grandpa never came back.

    Ponette: That's because no one was waiting for him.