The fire of war is always on everyone

Jarvis 2022-03-21 09:03:04

【26/100】 "Deutsche Year Zero" (Italian)

Before the opening, Gege had a conversation with Professor Pan Ruojian of Beijing Film Academy, and talked about several characteristics of Italian neorealist films: the creation took place during the war, the plot was weakened, the non-professional actors, and the camera was carried on the street to shoot.

Neorealist films are the only ones that take place before the war is over, so the picture is filled with the real ruins of Italy, dazed people and roads that don't end. The film is different, Rossellini observes as an outsider Berlin, Germany, the "sinner" of the war, the city that should have risen to world domination and is now in ruins.

In the film, the 12-year-old boy showed no expression from beginning to end, with the burden of the whole family on his shoulders, his father was about to go home, his brother was escaping from reality, and his sister was gossiped, and he could never find more money. At this time, the teacher said to me "natural selection", and the nurse pushed a bottle of poisonous medicine, what should I do? ——After killing my father, the teacher denied what he said, the kid who played football didn’t take me to play, the road couldn’t reach the end, the father’s coffin was pulled into the car in the distance, and the last slide was played from the steel beam slanted in the ruins , ended his life face down.

In the film, the camera moves with the little boy on the street, reflecting the confusion and desolation of the little boy's psychology, coupled with the occasional harsh music, in short, it reminds you all the time that you are not watching any comfortable film at all.

In reflecting on the war, Rossellini went too far. He did not give the audience any emotional comfort, like a calm surgeon, leaving behind an allegorical ending that requires the participation of the audience: the fire of war is on everyone , the aftermath of war is a disease that spreads to all mankind. Life after the war was extremely painful for the individual, no less than during the war.

View more about Germany Year Zero reviews

Extended Reading
  • Luigi 2022-03-26 09:01:12

    Rossellini is really changing, this film is not much different from Rome, Open City. The last paragraph of children wandering through the ruins is interesting. The soundtrack is devastatingly bad, unique to the US version?

  • Osbaldo 2022-03-24 09:03:24

    This is by no means a simple accusation of the Nazis. Henning's direct allusions to "Nazi ideas" are not many, and the cause of the final tragedy is not "wrong education" - as a neo-realist giant who experienced two world wars, Rossellini's observations and reflections on post-war Germany and even Europe are better than Facebook The historical narrative of the transformation is much more profound. In the first half, the camera focuses on the economic collapse and people's livelihood in post-war Germany, and in the second half, he spends a lot of space to show the isolation suffered by the protagonist. It is symbolic to review die Deutsche katastrophe (Friedrich Meinecke) or to worry about Germany's future. : Corresponding to Hitler's speech of mobilizing war and inciting hatred, people familiar with the history of the two world wars naturally understand that "poverty and despair are the breeding ground for extremism." The U.S. military took a group photo in front of the concentration camp, and listened to the Nazi broadcast. The Köhler family, his disabled father, and even the ex-Nazi brother who stood up to the resistance were quite morally upright... Interesting arrangement: Even today, when extremist thoughts are rampant, has its real value. It's just that the soundtrack is really confusing...

Germany Year Zero quotes

  • Edmund: I have no work, and neither does Eva. My brother still won't report and get his card.

    Il maestro: I understand, but what can I do?

    Edmund: My father needs treatment. Can't you help me? What can I do?

    Il maestro: There's nothing you can do. Times are hard for everyone, worse for weak and old people. You've done all you can.

    Edmund: But what if he dies?

    Il maestro: If he dies, he dies. We all die sooner or later. Would you rather die yourself or let an old man live?

  • Karl-Heinz: Who gave you money to buy cigarettes?

    Edmund: It was a gift.

    Karl-Heinz: From who? Those bad boys you go stealing with?

    Edmund: It wasn't boys. It was a girl.

    Karl-Heinz: You should be ashamed of yourself.

    Edmund: Why? Everybody does it.

    Karl-Heinz: That's not a reason.

    Edmund: Her name is Christl. She's all alone, and she sleeps in a basement. She's a nice girl. I like her. She gives cigarettes to all her friends. You should have a woman to take care of you.

    Karl-Heinz: A woman? That's all I need. Like this bitch of a life wasn't enough.

    Edmund: Don't talk like that! Have courage!

    Karl-Heinz: I had courage. A soldier can lose everything but his courage. But now I'm not a soldier anymore. I'm less than useless, another mouth to feed.