If there is a God, then there is a possibility that God exists.

Ferne 2022-03-22 09:02:28

In Bergman's films, there is a lot of discussion of God. In fact, I don't believe in the existence of God, but when watching Bergman's films, I can't help thinking about this issue. Of course, whether God exists or not is pseudoscience, and there is no way to prove it, so everything makes sense. If God is an abstract concept, and you have assumed it exists, then you will explain it. In this film, Karin interprets some sounds, and some images (real and imagined), as traces of God's presence. At the end, his father interprets love as God.

Then the problem comes, precisely because you first assumed the concept of God, and then you can't help but explain it. Of course, you must use non-scientific experience to explain it, otherwise it will be easily refuted. But for those of us who do not have the premise of God's existence, we will not be able to explain this mysterious word. Love is love to us, a mysterious voice is a mysterious voice, and a picture in fantasy is a picture in fantasy. So, we don't even have to think about whether God exists or not. Bergman, on the other hand, doubted God, and was only fighting against that assumption. Of course, this matter can also be said in a profound way: Bergman doubts God is fighting against the influence he has been subjected to, against a culture that has existed in Europe for many years.

View more about Through a Glass Darkly reviews

Extended Reading
  • Emery 2022-03-27 09:01:14

    He says Karin is surrounded by love and can be saved, but I don't believe it. I'd be grateful if all the fantasies of optimism persuaded me, or just aroused me for a moment. But almost... it's too hard.

  • Devon 2022-03-27 09:01:14

    Schizophrenic religious fanaticism and disillusionment. Bergman's works are indeed stuck in religious thinking for a lifetime and can't come out.

Through a Glass Darkly quotes

  • Fredrik: Father, I'm scared. When I was hugging Karin in the boat, reality was revealed. Do you know what I mean?

    David: I do.

    Fredrik: Reality was revealed, and I collapsed. It's like a dream. Anything can happen. Anything.

    David: I know.

    Fredrik: I can't live in this new world.

    David: Yes, you can. But you must have a support.

    Fredrik: What kind of support? You mean a God? Give me a proof of his existance. You can't.

    David: I can. But you gotta pay attention to what I say.

    Fredrik: Yes. I need to listen.

    David: I can only tell you a thought of my own hopes. It is to know that love exists for real in the human world.

    Fredrik: A sort of special love, I suppose?

    David: All kinds of it. The bigger and the smaller, the most absurd one and the most sublime one. All kinds of love.

    Fredrik: What about the desire for love?

    David: Desire and denying. Trust and distrust.

    Fredrik: Then love is the proof?

    David: I don't know if love is the proof of God's existance or if it's God itself.

    Fredrik: To you, love and God are the same thing.

    David: That thought makes me feel less empty; Makes my desperation less worse.

    Fredrik: Go on, dad.

    David: All of a sudden, emptiness turns into abundance, and desperation turns into life. It's like a temporary death's sentence strike.

    Fredrik: Dad... if it's like how you say it is, then God is all over Karin. We love her so much.

    David: Yes.

    Fredrik: Can't that help her?

    David: I think so.

  • Fredrik: Hey! Be careful now. Keep away from me. Stop hugging and kissing me. Stop sunbathing half naked. You disgust me. You know very well what I mean. Women are horrible. How they smell and move around, how they stick out their stomachs, how they comb their hair and talk. Makes me feel like a skinned rabbit!

    Karin: Poor boy.

    Fredrik: Thanks. I can give myself all the pity I want.