original

Lesley 2022-03-23 09:01:47

The original is much more delicate and complete than the movie, and the movie has changed a lot of key points. After all, it is difficult to explain clearly in 100 minutes. Perhaps we should be harsher and say that the director failed to catch it. "Breakup Letter" is actually the Chinese translation of the novel, which is quite fitting. In the novel, the letter that Savannah sent to John was rounded into a ball, but it was not thrown away or burned in the end. John kept the crumpled paragraphs.
In the original book, Shawenna married Tim not suddenly, Shawenna also loved Tim at the same time, but there was no lightning bolt like she did to John. Tim is Savannah's neighbor and grew up together. Tim has always been Savannah's harbour, especially during her emotional lows. (And Ellen is not Tim's son, but his younger brother. Savannah fell in love with Tim after a car accident that took the lives of Tim's parents. Just a few months after Savannah sent that breakup letter .)
If the protagonist is Tim, then the story becomes a boy next door who silently sacrifices to the heroine. After more than ten years of dedication, he finally gains his heart and even gets the approval of his rival. In this way, John became the fireworks that dazzled in Savannah's life, and Tim was the ever-lasting light.
But the protagonist is John, and the focus becomes the sincere emotion of choosing to leave for true love. In the novel Nicholas Sparks (nun shit *Starbucks) writes about knowing that leaving is true love, and expresses this subject through the letting go of two men. Before, it was Tim who even matched Savannah and John for the happiness of Savannah, and then begged John and Savannah to continue when he was dying. John learned that Savannah also loves Tim, and he didn't want to use a misfortune to rush back to his relationship with Savannah. After going through so much, John didn't want to see Savannah lose her lover again, so he chose to sell all the coins his father had collected to help Tim heal. This is John's letting go. Tim and John love by leaving at key moments. Although there are sacrifices, Tim's approach will be accepted by most people, and John's departure will be something that most people can't do. It is a sublimation of the subject of "leaving is true love". This makes the subject that the novel wants to express hierarchical. These backgrounds in the film are not mentioned at all, making the subject relatively thin.
The novel ends with Tim being cured. Savannah, Tim, and Ellen return to their normal lives. On a bright night, Savannah stepped out of the shelter of the eaves. She seemed to see something, but she looked around for a while but found nothing. In this quiet night, only the light of the full moon was clean. When Savannah stared at the full moon with her arms folded, another person was actually staring at her. -Finish-

View more about Dear John reviews

Extended Reading
  • Dee 2022-03-26 09:01:05

    Well, leaving is true love. I was looking forward to watching the actors and posters, and I didn't feel hopeful when I watched the trailer... After watching... well... It's just okay...

  • Charlie 2022-04-23 07:01:52

    It's hard for me to understand this woman's mind. Fraternity must be promised to each other? Must sacrifice the hero? OMG. I don't know anyway. The stars are all for the father of the male protagonist. This character is very real, three-dimensional and moving. I didn't watch anything else in this film, but focused on the father-son relationship. Not bi-directional, just father to son.

Dear John quotes

  • John Tyree: There's something I wanna tell you. After I got shot, you wanna know the very first thing that entered my mind? Before I blacked out? Coins. I'm eight years old again on a tour of the U.S. Mint. I'm listening to a guy explain how coins are made. How they're punched out of sheet metal. How they're rimmed and beveled. How they're stamped and cleaned. And how each and every batch of coin are personally examined just in case any of them slipped though with the slightest imperfection. That's what popped into my head. I'm a Coin of the United States Army. I was minted in the year 1980. I've been punched from sheet metal. I've been stamped and cleaned. My edges have been rimmed and beveled. But now I have two small holes in me. I'm no longer in perfect condition.

  • Savannah Curtis: Dear John. Tell me everything. Write everything down. That way, we will be with each other all the time even if we're not with each other at all.