Beloved Andrei

Norbert 2022-04-08 09:01:13

If there was ever a person in the world who convinced you that for the rest of your life, you would never fall in love with anyone else...

Andrei is the man in my mind. Although his father's stubborn thought remains in his genes - unable to bear Natasha's betrayal, his melancholy breath, and the real aristocratic temperament different from Pierre, attracted me so deeply that I can't understand Natasha's empathy after her death, even though the beginning and the end were written (it was Pierre who Natasha first fell in love with and never forgot).
This can only be blamed on the arrangement of the episodes. It's not easy for the BBC to condense a novel of nearly 1,100,000 words in six episodes and to develop it in an orderly manner, and the compact plot can avoid the boring family chores. But it also comes with its drawbacks, as Tolstoy's proud psychological descriptions of characters are missing, or at least incomplete, making many important plot twists ridiculous. For example, Natasha's irrepressible love for Pierre's wife and brother (in fact, I can't understand Natasha's most emotional transformation and catharsis).
James Norton made me fall in love with Prince Andrei so much that I could not even bear it after his death.
ps. Natasha did shine in adulthood but with such a plot arrangement and Lily James she acted like Somewhat neurotic, at least not likable enough to be accepted as Andrei's true lover.

View more about War & Peace reviews

Extended Reading
  • Bernadette 2022-04-10 09:01:08

    Actually at most 2 stars

  • Mortimer 2022-04-03 09:01:12

    Makes me want to re-read the original! I only read the original book once when I was in junior high school. At that time, I was too young to feel heavy. The BBC is too conscientious this year!

War & Peace quotes

  • [first lines]

    Anna Pavlovna Scherer: But mon cher ami, how can you be so calm? This... this monster, Bonaparte - he's crossed into Austria now and... who's to say that Russia won't be next.

  • [last lines]

    Pierre Bezukhov: [voice-over] They say sufferings are misfortunes. But if I was asked, would I stay as I was before I was taken prisoner, or go through it all again? I would say for God's sake, let me be a prisoner again.

    Pierre Bezukhov: Come, let's sit and eat and give thanks for our good fortune.

    Pierre Bezukhov: [voice-over continued] When our lives are knocked off course, we imagine everything in them is lost. But it is only the start of something new and good. As long as there is life, there is happiness. There is a great deal... a great deal still to come.