The answer is in the wind

Donato 2022-03-25 09:01:19

The wind will carry us

"Gone With the Wind", like all the previous works of director Abbas, narrates the true meaning of life through concise and plain language under the beautiful picture. The film tells the story of an engineer who follows his team to a small remote mountain village. He is interested in everything in the village: talking to children, chatting with villagers, caring for the elderly... But everything backfires. The pit dug by the villagers collapsed and the villagers were buried alive. The doctor went to rescue the villagers. At the same time, the old man was also terminally ill.

Just like what he used in "The Taste of Cherry" before, the director still uses the hero to express his sigh and melancholy about the impermanence of life, and at the same time, he once again threw this doubt to the audience by leaving blank at the end.

It is worth noting that Abbas, who has always been good at detail description, also paved the way for the subsequent development of the plot through two dialogues between the engineer and the little boy in this film, and also provided the audience with a solution to the above confusion:

Child: I still have one question to answer. Fourth question.

Engineer: You don't know the answer?

Child: I don't know, because I can't.

Engineer: What is it?

Child: "On Judgment Day, how will good and evil be judged?"

Engineer: That's pretty obvious, good people go to hell and bad people go to heaven. Is it right?

child: yes

Engineer: No... Good people go to heaven, bad people go to hell.

-------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------

(Second conversation)

Engineer: I want to apologize for what happened this morning. Do you remember the first day you asked why the car didn't work? I replied "it's dead" do you remember?

Engineer: We drove up the mountain that day and the car died.

Child: Yes.

Engineer: He worked too hard and died.

Child: Yes.

Engineer: What did I say, cars are like people, they die. Now I want to say again.... People are like machines, they die.

At the end of the film, as the engineer threw the symbolic bone into the river, he seemed to have found the answer at that moment. Sitting in front of the computer at the moment, I am still faced with this confusion of "the dead are so stubborn, who will not give up day and night", and the answer may be in the wind, and what I can do is to wait for the wind to rise again. Wind chase.

View more about The Wind Will Carry Us reviews

Extended Reading
  • Vito 2022-03-15 09:01:07

    Most of the comments focused on the beauty of Abbas’ images, but it seemed that the story was not understood correctly. The story is about (should) a TV reporter covering the funeral ceremony of the ignorant feudal village in the village. The reporter and his friends live in the village and wait for their report material, that is, the death of an old man in the village. But day by day, the old man's condition gradually improved, but his friends and leaders urged him to go back and give up the report. In the middle of the journey, the reporter encountered a villager who was buried alive. He drove around to tell, and finally managed to rescue him. In the early hours of the next morning, when the reporter drove away from the village, he found that the old man had passed away. The villagers walked towards the old man in black clothes. The reporter just took a few photos and left. This actually means that when a person is really facing death, he realizes the heavy cruelty of death, and also understands his ignorance and selfishness in hopes that the old man will die soon and become his own report material. The wind blowing wheat waves, the most beautiful part, is also the only experience he has left his driving seat. The words of the doctor (philosopher) inspired him. After he left the village, he threw the bones found in the cemetery into the river.

  • Lorenz 2022-03-18 09:01:06

    Abbas’s Country Poem won the 1999 Venice Jury Prize. 1. Abbas secretly observed a village from the perspective of an outsider intruder. The engineer in the film also "sneak shot" of women twice (one time was stopped by the cafe owner, and the other time he took a group portrait while bidding farewell). 2. People say that Abbas made a topographical movie. Just like every time he answers the phone, he has to go out and drive to a commanding height. In the endless repetition, every time there is a difference. 3. The golden land of the Iranian Plateau, verdant trees, vast distant mountains, fighting puppies, grazing sheep, farmhouses with vertical drop, apples falling to the ground, tortoise kicking and dung beetles pushing dung balls , There are also the circuitous roads and occasional views of God in Abbas’s iconic vision, and the poetry of nature and daily life flows through it. 4. Throw the thigh bones excavated from the highland graves into the creek and drift away with the waves. 5. The whole shaving process is shown in front of the camera, just like a ceremony, and the two small talks show interesting differences (how many girls and how many boys? -5 girls and 4 boys; -5 girls and 5 boys) . 6. No diploma is required to write poems. (8.5/10)

Top cast

The Wind Will Carry Us quotes

  • Engineer: Hurry up. Get in.

    Farzad: I can't come now.

    Engineer: Why?

    Farzad: I need one more answer for the exam.

    Engineer: What is it?

    Farzad: The fourth question.

    Engineer: You don't know the answer?

    Farzad: No.

    Engineer: Why?

    Farzad: Because I don't.

    Engineer: What was it?

    Farzad: What happens to the good and the evil on Judgment day? "

    Engineer: That's obvious: the good go to Hell, and the evil go to Heaven. Is that right?

    Farzad: Yes.

    Engineer: No. the good go to Heaven, and the evil go to Hell. Hurry in and write that, then come back.

  • Engineer: But it wasn't Farhad who dug Behistun.

    Hole Digger: I know.

    Engineer: Who Then?

    Hole Digger: It was love. The love of Shirin.

    Engineer: Bravo! You must know love.

    Hole Digger: A man without love cannot live.