A mixed-reputation anti-typing experiment

Josie 2022-03-28 09:01:04

Despite being touted by the press as the 21st-century Taxi Driver when it was released in France, Lynne Ramsey's overly stylized work is nothing more than an anti-genre experiment with mixed reviews. The film won Best Actor and Best Screenplay at Cannes last year, and there's no need to say much about Joaquin Phoenix's superb performance, and the screenplay, in my opinion, really isn't a success. The rough and omitted script cannot fully shape the character. The hero part can still use flashback clips to let the audience piece together his past family background and painful experiences in their minds. The clue of the hero and the little girl is unclear. The handling is undoubtedly regrettable. There are only two or three scenes before and after that cannot make people appreciate the progressive development of the relationship between each other, and the most critical turning point is not convincing (why did the actor give up his life to save the girl?). It's easy to see that the director is trying to subvert the audience's expectations for the same genre, portraying the killer's frail character, swapping the relationship between the two in "This Killer is Not Too Cold", refusing to show violence head-on, and blending into the noirism of the Coen brothers. The sense of humor (the actor holding hands with another killer before he dies) is a refreshing and bold attempt. Not to mention the director's usual authoritative label: sharp flashback editing, inspiring electronic soundtrack, psychologically suggestive color set. However, the pale and concise narrative is about to be submerged in the overly dazzling image style, which makes the anti-type experiment unable to give full emotional touch, which is the biggest flaw of the film.

View more about You Were Never Really Here reviews

Extended Reading
  • Brandy 2022-04-20 09:01:47

    Falling into the slag of the past consciousness, the selectivity and moderation of violence, the funeral with humanity, nature and the sacred, death and rebirth in water, relying on the completion of resistance, an inescapable sad life, illusory suicide to achieve a false climax. The mother who committed suicide and the father who was abusive were nightmares from the past, and the father and mother who were also murdered completely broke the bond between the prostitute and the killer. No matter where you are going, today is a good day.

  • Alexandra 2022-04-21 09:02:27

    Although there are only more than 80 minutes, the director gave two endings with false and real methods. Regarding life, everyone can make a choice: You were never really here, or, its a beautiful day.

You Were Never Really Here quotes

  • Senator Votto: McCleary said you were brutal.

    Joe: ...I can be.

    Senator Votto: I want you to hurt them.

  • Joe: [To the father of a missing girl, referring to a lead as to where she might be] If she's there, I'll get her back.