A Wilder movie that isn't quite Wilder

Will 2021-12-22 08:01:04

The change is not just that the story stage moved from the city to the camp. Unlike Wilder's previous late-range effort style, "Stalag 17" is obviously vented at the end. The turning point at the end is too blunt, and the villain’s sudden thunderstorm will make people sigh with emotion: That’s it? Can't help but wonder if the old man was subjected to force majeure intervention when shooting this movie, so that he could not completely let go and had to make such compromises.

Although you can imagine the joy of people watching this movie, looking at the characters in the prisoner of war camp from today's perspective, it is inevitable that they will feel that they are too facial.

The Shuabao duo has almost shaken off 80% of the burden of the entire film, bringing the cheerful elements that a comedy should have, but its contribution to the movie stops there. The removal of these two characters seems to have no effect on the story. .

There is also Joey who plays the ocarina and the lieutenant’s men. These two characters have a lot of role in the movie and laid a lot of ground, but in the end, the trend of the plot (here more than refers to the traitor) was not as expected. Generally played a role in fueling the flames.

Although Horton is glamorous in this movie, the arc of the role is far less full than in "Sunset Boulevard". But fortunately, the line spoken to the roommates with a bit of hatred-"If we meet on the street in the future, we shall pretend not to know each other."-finally saved the character from the clichés. This line may be one of the keys for Horton to win the best actor Oscar with this film.

It's worth mentioning that the cunning German guard who was in the upper and lower faces of the prisoner-of-war camp and had to eat and drink was impressive enough. Behind the usual grinning and honest expression, there is a shuddering horror.

Just thinking of so much for the time being, this movie can basically be regarded as Billy Wilder's moderate level.

Finally, I would like to ask if the sisters in the comments that this movie objectifies women everywhere are tired. Why is this

View more about Stalag 17 reviews

Extended Reading
  • Albert 2022-04-24 07:01:14

    Light ropes and chess pieces. The alarm clock that goes to work happily. Where there are people, there is business. The prison camp is also similar to the theme of King Rat.

  • Evans 2022-04-21 09:02:28

    During World War II, Americans' attitudes toward Nazis and Germans were surprisingly humorous. Even in POW conditions, life went on and people needed laughter. Billy Wilder made this scene into an unusually good movie. It should be recognized that until the end of the war, and we saw films about concentration camps, the extent of the Nazi terror in Europe was not known. William Holden plays Sergeant Sefton, whose amoral cynicism and talent for cheap scams allowed him to feed himself even as a prisoner of war. Starger 17 has been widely imitated, and Roberto Benigni's Life is Beautiful, also finds humor in horror, but of a different kind. Like Ionesco's Rhino, Benny's films come from the Absurdist theater, not the Broadway stage. A jarring mix of comedy and dramatic elements that has an impact on our psyche because life is, in a way, very real, full of tragedy and laughs.

Stalag 17 quotes

  • Animal: [watching Sefton cook an egg] Are you gonna eat it all by yourself?

    Sefton: Mm-hmm. The yellow and the white.

    Animal: Is all right if we smell it?

    Sefton: Just don't drool on it.

    Shapiro: You're not gonna eat the shells?

    Sefton: Help yourself.

    Animal: [Harry gives him half the shell] Hey, thanks. What are we gonna do with it?

    Shapiro: We're gonna plant it, Animal. We're gonna grow us a chicken for Christmas.

  • Price: How come you were so sure Manfredi and Johnson wouldn't get out of the forest?

    Sefton: I wasn't so sure. I just liked the odds. What's that crack supposed to mean?

    Price: They're lying dead out there in the mud and I'm trying to find out how come.

    Sefton: I'll tell you how come. Because you, our security officer, said it'd be safe.

    [to Hoffy]

    Sefton: And you, the barracks chief, gave them the green light. That's how come. What are you guys trying to prove, anyway? Cuttin' trap doors, digging tunnels.

    Duke: Listen, Sefton...

    Sefton: You listen to me! What do you think the chances are of gettin' out of here? And let's say you make it to Switzerland. Let's say to the States. So what? They ship you out to the Pacific, slap you in another plane, and you get shot down again. Only this time you wind up in a Japanese prison camp. That is if you're lucky. Well, I'm no escape artist. Cigar, Cookie. You can be the heroes, the guys with fruit salad on your chest. Me, I'm stayin' put. And I'm gonna make myself as comfortable as I can. And if it takes a little trading with the enemy to get me some food or a better mattress, that's okay by Sefton.

    Duke: [Sefton lights a match on his jacket sleeve] Why, you crud. This war's gonna be over someday. Then what you do you think we'll do to Kraut-kissers like you?