Clint Eastwood's Feminism

Ashley 2022-04-21 09:01:36

I don't know if the director intended it or not, but the feminist color is sprinkled on the film deeply and shallowly. Even though I know that this is not the focus of the film, I have always been very sensitive to it, and I have caught some of it inadvertently.
(1) Women under oppression
In the mental hospital, only female mentally ill patients can be seen. The movie never mentions that it is a mental hospital that only treats female mentally ill patients. So why are there so many female patients? Are all mentally ill women?
Carol Dexter, the first prostitute to speak to Collins in the mental hospital, said this when she first communicated with her: "...Everyone knows women are vulnerable, they think women are emotional animals, go It doesn't matter, as long as the woman says something that makes them unhappy, he will fucking frame the woman as a lunatic..." Rather than saying that this is the reason why category 12 patients enter the mental hospital, I prefer to believe that It was the situation of American women in the 1930s (and, of course, women elsewhere were not much better). Vulnerability, sensibility, submissiveness... This was the woman in the eyes of men at that time, and it was also the stereotype of women in society.
When it comes to Dexter, she has to mention her identity as a prostitute. After she was electrocuted, she lay on her hospital bed and said feebly to Collins, "I went to the underground doctor to have two miscarriages, and there was no choice, no chance of keeping them, and you have, don't give up." She The helplessness is not only because he has no choice to save the child, but also because he can only go to the underground doctor to have an abortion. As a prostitute, not only is her right to be a mother deprived, but her right to maintain her own health is not even upheld. This is a woman's tragedy.
This oppression from a patriarchal society leads to a woman's revolt, which can be seen in Dexter as well as in Collins. She had this conversation with Dexter:
- "A serious woman shouldn't say such indecent things."
- "Damn it. In this case, it's a decent word."
She thought at first that serious women shouldn't Swearing is also in line with the expectations of society for women at that time. But later, when she faced the doctor's questioning, she directly broke out swear words. Her transformation can be seen as a transformation of women under the oppression of a patriarchal society.
(2) Women in the workplace
Where Collins works, the densely packed mess of operators is all female. That is to say, most of the people who are engaged in the lowest, simplest and most uncreative jobs are women. It's a pity that this was the case so many years ago, and it hasn't changed much now.
When Collins was off work, her boss once said to her: "Just wanted to tell you that I was very shocked, the first time I suggested hiring a female administrator, the boss didn't quite agree with the idea, but you do it as well as your male colleagues. "When a woman's job is as good as a man's, it shocks a man. In the eyes of a man, what kind of working state is a woman originally? When someone suggested hiring a female administrator, the boss disagreed. It is conceivable how difficult it is for women to develop in the workplace.
(3) Other rights of women The
pastor Collins said before visiting prison: "You are about to become the first woman in this state in 30 years who can visit a prison before execution." I think his emphasis should be on "Ms." , because it is a woman, so this matter is worth mentioning, otherwise it should be a common thing; it is also because women have never enjoyed this kind of rights that men can enjoy before, so this matter is worth mentioning carry.
(4) The tacit understanding between women
After Collins left the mental hospital, she helped other women who were not mentally ill in the mental hospital to leave the mental hospital. After Dexter walked out of the door of the mental hospital, instead of running out immediately like the others, she stayed there for a while, looking at Collins and smiling at her. I was moved by this scene for a long time. This is a smile that only exists between women. It belongs to the tacit understanding between women and has nothing to do with anything else.

View more about Changeling reviews

Extended Reading
  • Hubert 2022-03-21 09:01:32

    Worst work I've seen so far. Jolie single-handedly picked the role of the main heroine, and her acting skills were obviously going to be behind the scenes. In terms of drama, there are too many things to include, resulting in a loose structure and an unbalanced emotional foreshadowing. In the second half of the courtroom drama, the tension it should have was not achieved. This can be compared horizontally with "First Degree Fear". There are bright spots in the playlist, especially the scene in the mental hospital and the final hanging. It is a pity that it still falls into the old way of adapting real events. The characters are numerous and complex and the key points are not prominent. Many characters have become tools to promote the development of the plot, such as the arrested prostitute and the mother who survived the boy. Captain" is obviously more sensible in material stitching. The theme is deep enough, and this incident is used as a mirror to reflect the status quo of a specific era in the United States, so that the film's practical significance is greater than its artistic achievements. But the biggest flaw is also here - as a noir film, the ending actually tampered with the historical truth to give Cristine's so-called "hope", which is completely superfluous.

  • Abagail 2022-03-22 09:01:28

    Zhuan: You say that it is based on the United States in the 1920s and 1930s, or that it is based on China in the early 2000s. Both are established. Isn't it because the victim's family petitioned and locked up as a neuropathy? This kind of thing happens every day here, and it continues every day. .

Changeling quotes

  • Detective Lester Ybarra: Dig. You put them in the ground, now you can take them out. You heard me. Dig.

  • [first lines]

    Christine Collins: Walter, honey. Time to wake up.

    Walter Collins: Just ten more minutes...

    Christine Collins: Sorry, sport. You can sleep in tomorrow, that's what Saturdays are for.