-
Blaise 2023-04-19 05:14:27
Halfway through the film, I began to suspect that under the East German system at that time, there would not be a secret police like Wiesmann. Knowing the dark side of the system and the complexity and darkness of human nature makes me not believe in such an overly "easy" recovery of personality. Brecht's poems, Beethoven's piano pieces, yes, fascinating, always my favorite, and women, those beautiful things. . However, are they really that easy to impress? Are they enough to fight the system?...
-
Levi 2023-04-15 01:28:32
The last "pure land" of "democratic" Germany. This era of white terror in which everyone is under surveillance and has no freedom is truly terrifying. Even the time was deliberately set in 1984. The film begins with a two-line narrative, and later it turns to a single line [actually, it is still a double line in a sense]. Fortunately, the Berlin Wall has fallen, but in some other countries, the Berlin Wall is still going on. However, such "good people" with a conscience are too...
-
Karley 2023-04-11 10:41:48
The songs in the film are also very...
-
Keshaun 2023-04-02 20:12:52
A sonata for a good...
-
Vincent 2023-03-30 22:42:20
In a concept similar to 1984, it is much more tender. This is more poetic than a pen soldier should have. Other People's Lives is a good...
-
Renee 2023-02-28 17:33:02
The Chinese translation is too bad. When I heard the name, I thought it was a fourth-rate action movie, so I didn't watch...
-
Trevor 2023-02-23 11:21:18
German artwork with superb precision in performance, camera language, story pacing and emotional handling. Generally speaking, it still remains in the imagination of capitalism's presupposition of liberal democracy, so the perspective of the future Snowden era is insufficient. However, I will still be moved by the individual characters prominent in the film. At least that's a level we can't reach. I feel that the viewing of movies these days has been controlled by the subconscious mind of...
-
Jerald 2023-01-22 17:37:57
Someday You'll Be a Story, the author of "German History" thinks that "Eavesdropping Storm" is too lengthy and sensational, and deliberately emphasizes the exaggeration of the Stasi's position in East Germany. Audiences who do not know the historical truth are easily deceived by horrific stories, thinking that this is the The portrayal of the daily life of most East Germans, and said that viewers who are not familiar with history but have normal understanding can also see the plot loopholes,...
-
Perry 2023-01-22 03:09:16
Under the weight of the system, many people get lost. Someone's kindness is trivial under the system. It might save lives, or it might not be too late. But in any case, for this man, he rebelled against the whole system with his own power. He could always say that I lived for myself, not wasted my life for a cold...
-
Alex 2022-12-30 22:25:29
[Exhibition at China Film Archive] 6 years and 9 days ago, I watched this film on a small MP4 under the quilt. I would not have thought that I could enjoy this classic again on the big screen (in an equally totalitarian country) today. Movie. Even the machines within the system ("1984", "We") can still shine with the brilliance of human nature. It is true that the film is very idealistic, and there is no such thing in the real East Germany. But it can awaken everyone's...
The Lives of Others Comments
-
Adelbert 2022-01-25 08:03:32
Eavesdropping storm
The story took place in Berlin, East Germany in 1984. In order to grasp the people's ideological dynamics, the National Security Bureau used extreme monitoring and interrogation. Many artists were "suicided." History is always surprisingly similar, so during the Cultural Revolution, intellectuals...
-
Doris 2022-04-19 09:01:22
Typical Prussian style
At the beginning of the year, when I was in Munich to see the party for the Bayern Film Awards, I told W beside me that I must watch this film. It is a spiritual leap to document the Germans' journey from celebrating unity to examining history.
After returning to Beijing for more than half a year,...
-
Oberstleutnant Anton Grubitz: I have to show you something: "Prison Conditions for Subversive Artists: Based on Character Profile". Pretty scientific, eh? And look at this: "Dissertation Supervisor, A. Grubitz". That's great, isn't it? I only gave him a B. They shouldn't think getting a doctorate with me is easy. But his is first-class. Did you know that there are just five types of artists? Your guy, Dreyman, is a Type 4, a "hysterical anthropocentrist." Can't bear being alone, always talking, needing friends. That type should never be brought to trial. They thrive on that. Temporary detention is the best way to deal with them. Complete isolation and no set release date. No human contact the whole time, not even with the guards. Good treatment, no harassment, no abuse, no scandals, nothing they could write about later. After 10 months, we release. Suddenly, that guy won't cause us any more trouble. Know what the best part is? Most type 4s we've processed in this way never write anything again. Or paint anything, or whatever artists do. And that without any use of force. Just like that. Kind of like a present.
-
Georg Dreyman: The state office for statistics on Hans-Beimler street counts everything; knows everything: how many pairs of shoes I buy a year: 2.3, how many books I read a year: 3.2 and how many students graduate with perfect marks: 6,347. But there's one statistic that isn't collected there, perhaps because such numbers cause even paper-pushers pain: and that is the suicide rate.
Director: Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck
Language: German Release date: March 30, 2007