This is a too grand proposition. The O'Brien family was in mourning when their second son died at the age of 19. Why does a young and beautiful life suddenly fall? Why did such a kind and pious young man suffer such bad luck? What is behind the impermanence of the world? what is the meaning of life? Where will humanity go from here?
Terrence Malick, who is known for his philosophical speculation and aesthetic images, has continued and expanded his style this time. The narration of constantly asking questions and the blending of man and nature have become the signature, and this film is even more endless, directly interspersed. It is a 20-minute popular science film from the Big Bang, the origin of life, the extinction of dinosaurs, to the final destruction of the earth and the mutation of the sun. Looking at today's film industry, it's probably only Malick who can "fuck" like this in a mainstream drama with Brad Pitt and Sean Penn. This is also the biggest controversy caused by this film: some people are full of praise, some people (scolding) are bloody sprays; if it is good to say it is high and low, and it is bad to say it is self-admiring. But no matter what, surviving the dizzy screen like playing music with mediapalyer without falling asleep, and then watching Jack recall how he went from repression to rebellion to confusion to reconciliation, while thinking about the problems in the narration, is the key to understanding this film. .
The director's answer is to resort to religion, which is related to his Christian family background. The excerpt from the book of Job at the beginning of the film coincides with the misfortune of the O'Brien family, teaching people to be like Job who, despite being deprived of wealth, children, and health for no reason, remain faithful to God. That mysterious arc of light that recurs is undoubtedly the incarnation of God, who has no form but is everywhere; he created the world, and the world will eventually perish, but those who believe in him will have eternal life in another world. Finally, the grown-up Jack reunites on the beach with the most perfect parents and brothers in his mind, sharing eternal happy moments.
Religious enlightenment, trials, and destination are not topics discussed in this review. Speaking of the film alone, the director's ambition and efforts are admirable, but it is the greatest regret that the divinity and humanity have not been truly integrated. Originally, wanting to use a movie to discuss such a broad topic is really difficult for some strong people. It's not easy to arouse some people's thoughts and feelings. As for the box office, you don't need to care too much.
By the way, does Sean Penn really know what he's doing?
View more about The Tree of Life reviews
