<Jane Eyre> Brief Comment

Annamae 2022-04-19 09:02:05

Looking back at the 2011 version of "Jane Eyre", the biggest surprise is to find that the director of the film is Kerry Fukunaga, who will be famous in the industry for directing "True Detective" and writing "The Clown" in the future. Noisy director, whose dark and gloomy video style can already be seen in his early works, it is no wonder that when I recall the scattered memories left when I watched this film for the first time in junior high school, a sense of horror came to my mind Spread; under the shadowy Gothic castle building at the beginning, Jane Eyre, who ran wild in the dark night, set an uneasy tone for the whole film.

The heroine of Charlotte Brontë's "Jane Eyre" is the central character of this gothic novel - the dark and gloomy secrets of the past are buried under the innocent appearance of Jane Love like a castle. Roger Ebert put it this way: "Part of what appeals to us about gothic romance is the feeling that the erotic lust escapes beneath the surface of the narrative." The teenage girl is drawn to a male protagonist who is as dangerous as a vampire. The girl's setting is usually helpless, pitiful, and tragic, but at the same time she is also brave, self-respecting and full of feminism. In Brontë's works, the male protagonist Rochester undertakes another part of the narrative tension of the story, and in the adaptation of this version of the film, Fassbender's version of Rochester is a little less violent, More gentle from the beginning.

This should also be related to the design of the film’s narrative structure. The film adopts an interlude method, starting with Jane Eyre’s departure from the manor, and focusing on the part of Jane Eyre’s role as a tutor in Thornfield, while Jane Eyre was an orphan in her early years. The experiences of the academy and Loward School are interluded, and many plots are also chosen due to the two-hour time limit. This may also be the reason why it is difficult for me to feel the complex emotions between the two when they met and fell in love. The love experience between Jane Eyre and Rochester seems to me to be abrupt, and at the same time, it is more obvious. The love experience is regarded as the highlight of the film, which is in conflict with the feminism that this book is trying to express.

"My soul is the same as yours, and my heart is exactly the same as yours!" The author first came across this book when I was a child. It is usually classified as a love enlightenment book, but in fact it is not. This is a book about the growth of young girls. The book, Brontë chronicles the painful choices a girl must make amid a dilemma. It is true that the film's handling of the final third act of the wedding is excellent, but under the premise of abrupt love variations, it is difficult to reflect the criticism of the patriarchal class.

Going back to the creation of the film, there is no doubt that the art director of this film put a lot of energy into restoring the background of the 19th century medieval classical manor, and the whole film almost only uses natural light to abandon the lighting strategy, which also makes Kerry Fuyong. —The director of thrillers, who is good at creating an almost horror atmosphere — has plenty of room to play. And this is also in sharp contrast to the final scene of the film, which is set outdoors, a manor filled with bright trees and greenery. When Jane Eyre finally made a firm choice and held Rochester's hands, it also symbolized that she finally stepped out of her sad past and faced the light - that is, accepting herself.

View more about Jane Eyre reviews

Extended Reading
  • Marianna 2021-12-15 08:01:14

    How many roads a woman has to run to get closer to her ideal self; how much fire a man has to burn before she can learn to love again; the butler Fairfax is unprecedentedly rich and subtle, and Judy Dench really suppressed the field; Mia Wasikowska still carried Alice's one. Face suspicion formed a wonderful intertextual relationship; flashbacks from Jane Eyre's departure provide a new perspective.

  • Evert 2021-12-15 08:01:14

    There are many people who complain about remakes of famous books, but I like them very much. Exquisite costumes, scenes, and melodious and elegant music, probably I just love watching such beautiful movies. When Mia is not speaking, her eyes can show the perseverance, and her collarbone is so beautiful~~

Jane Eyre quotes

  • [last lines]

    Rochester: [sightless] Who's there?

    Jane Eyre: [takes his hand]

    Rochester: This hand.

    [touching her face]

    Rochester: Jane Eyre. Jane Eyre.

    Jane Eyre: Edward, I am come back to you... Fairfax Rochester with nothing to say?

    Rochester: You're altogether a human being Jane.

    Jane Eyre: I conscientiously believe so.

    Rochester: [passionate kiss] I dream.

    Jane Eyre: Awaken then.

    [they embrace]

  • Rochester: I know you; you're thinking. Talking is of no use, you're thinking how to act.

    Jane Eyre: All has changed sir. I must leave you.

    Rochester: No. No. Jane do you love me.

    [Jane nods]

    Rochester: Then the essential things are the same. Be my wife.

    Jane Eyre: You have a wife.

    Rochester: I pledge you my honor, my fidelity...

    Jane Eyre: You cannot.

    Rochester: ...my love until death do us part.

    Jane Eyre: What of truth?

    Rochester: I would have told you the truth.

    Jane Eyre: You are deceitful sir.

    Rochester: I was wrong to deceive you. I see that now, it was cowardly. I should have appealed to your spirit as I do now. Bertha Antoinette Mason, she was wanted by my father for her fortune. I hardly spoke with her before the wedding. I lived with her for 4 years. Her temper ripened, her vices sprang up, violent and unchaste. Only cruelty would check her and I'd not use cruelty. I was chained to her for life Jane. Not even the law could free me. Have you ever set foot in a mad house Jane?

    Jane Eyre: No sir.

    Rochester: The inmates are caged and baited like beasts. I spared her that at least. Jane?

    Jane Eyre: Yes I pity you sir.

    Rochester: Who would you offend by living with me? Who would care?

    Jane Eyre: I would.

    Rochester: You would rather drive me to madness than break some mere human law.

    Jane Eyre: I must respect myself.

    Rochester: Listen to me. Listen. I could bend you with my finger and my thumb. A mere reed you feel in my hands. But whatever I do with this cage, I cannot get at you, and it is your soul that I want. Why can't you come of your own free will?

    Jane Eyre: God help me.