What are the differences between "Green Book" and real events?

Mozelle 2022-03-15 09:01:02

The real Don Shirley is not someone who is far away from the black community and does not understand black music. He is actively involved in the black civil rights movement. He is a friend of Dr. King and participated in the parade in Selma together. He is very close friends with black musicians Nina Simone, Duke Ellington and Sarah Vaughn.

The real Don Shirley is not alienated from his family. It is said in the movie that he has only one brother who is not in contact. In fact, he had three close brothers at the time. After the death of one of the brothers' wife, he almost raised two nephews who had no mothers.

According to Don Shirley's family, Don Shirley and Tony did not establish a real friendship, and their relationship is the relationship between an ordinary employer and an employee. Tony did not work for Don Shirley for long and was fired. The fact is that Tony's son Nick Vallelonga is one of the writers of the film. The film only chooses one person's narrative without referring to (or respecting) the other's narrative. However, this is only a film, not a documentary, and it may not be very important to not restore the facts.

Don Shirley's family was interviewed after the movie was broadcast and expressed considerable dissatisfaction with the movie. For more detailed and accurate content, please refer to the link below (the details of the interview are included) https://shadowandact.com/the-real-donald-shirley-green-book-hollywood-swallowed-whole

However, in the follow-up, director Green Book responded to Don Shirley's family accusations. What is the truth? Because the death of the two people in the world may not be confirmed at all. Right or wrong can only be decided by each. https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2019/01/green-book-director-peter-farrelly-defends-movie-against-criticism

View more about Green Book reviews

Extended Reading
  • Greyson 2022-03-25 09:01:05

    I know why Spike Lee hates this movie so much. It's the opposite of "Black Gangster". It is also the "good brother" model of the combination of white and black. "Green Book" talks about the influence of the two being changed. Of course, most of them are the changes of black pianists. The conversion of white Italians is almost negligible, but "Black Party Member" is also a black man who wants to integrate into the white class, but he is not at all lost in his identity. Instead, he has been respected with his character and abilities from beginning to end. The expression of discrimination in "Green Book" is dull and direct, while "Black Party Members" is ridiculous and ironic, making judgments. "Green Book" is Hollywood The successful assembly line work, and "Black Party Member" is the authorization of Spike Lee through the classic Hollywood narrative model. Its anti-climax, its "tribute", and its "routine" are extremely profound. However, the discussion of identity in "Green Book" has always felt like an ordinary road movie.

  • Dannie 2022-03-24 09:01:16

    The audience in the theater likes the constant laughter. It is true that there are some American sensationalism and white self-salvation, but it is impossible to ignore the ingenuity of the script itself. The overall degree of completion is also good, but the second policeman and the bridge section of Christmas Eve made me roll my eyes a few times.

Green Book quotes

  • Dr. Don Shirley: Ahh that was a good time. I'd do that once a month for free.

  • Tony Lip: I don't make the rules down here.

    Dr. Don Shirley: No? Then who does?

    Tony Lip: You're saying just 'cause I'm white and they're white? You know, that's a very prejudiced thing you just said there. A very prejudiced thing. I got more in common with the Hymies at 2nd Avenue Deli than I do with these hillbilly pricks down here.