Confederation or Confederation

Willow 2022-01-17 08:02:45

The rise and fall of American cinema conforms to the laws of the stages of the development of things. However, in view of the relatively free and open state system of the United States, there can always be two green grasses in the hills full of rotten patches.

My understanding of the American Civil War originated from high school history textbooks, which are naturally pretending to be compelling. Don't tell everyone the truth, just tell everyone the meaning, the meaning is still taken for granted. After reading "Gods and Generals", I probably learned that the American Civil War was basically fought in Virginia, and the purpose of the war was for the Confederation or the Confederacy.

Anyone who has taken a middle school history class knows that the cause of the American Civil War was caused by "Uncle Tom's Cabin". What the film in the play tells us is that this is not a war about justice, but a war about fairness. In other words, the U.S. central government and the Virginia local government fought a cruel match on the battlefield based on the principle of fairness. And the abolition movement is nothing but a label put on the game by the northern government. Of course, the label affixed by the southern government is freedom. So from a formal point of view, this game is called the battle of "human power and free will".

Having been educated in China for many years, I have always sympathized with the North for the American Civil War. One is that people who are willing to sacrifice their lives for the rights of others are respectable, and secondly, the North has suffered a series of miserable defeats. After watching the film, I turned to sympathize with the South. This army, which was dressed in ragged clothes, could not afford to live in a tent, and could not even drink sweet potato soup, faced the well-equipped northern army and treated death as if at home, and generously killed the enemy. Although the northern army is also exceptionally brave, the generals in the north are just like their masters (big bankers, big industrialists), and they exude an aura of greed. In contrast, the generals of the southern army showed noble cultivation and rigorous qualities. Therefore, to compare which General Li and Hu Ke met the standards of a good general, this vote went to Li without hesitation.

In addition, by observing the North and South "Stonewall Generals" Jackson and Chamberlain, I found an outstanding character who can demonstrate his excellence in every word and deed in his daily life. Therefore, if you find a person who is accustomed to spoofing or complaining, you must be careful. Most of these people have no precious qualities to be proud of for you to learn and imitate, and most of these people are People who have not succeeded in success, and who have suffered more than failure.

View more about Gods and Generals reviews

Extended Reading
  • Antwon 2022-03-25 09:01:19

    Civil War Textbook Movies

  • Kale 2022-04-23 07:03:56

    I mainly came to see the Confederate twin stars "Stonewall" Jackson and Robert Lee, especially "Stonewall". I personally think he was the first general of the Civil War. General Lee had a good plan, but he was not flexible enough to implement it. Be careful, so it is easy to make bugs, and Jackson handles details more carefully than Li is flexible. If he does not die, I am afraid that the North Army will have to pay more sacrifices, and it will cost a lot more to win. The Northern Army won the battle with more people and more money. In addition, the "Three Lights Policy" invented by Sherman deterred the South. The shooting angle of the film is relatively objective and neutral. It did not depreciate the Southern Army because it belonged to a slave state, nor did it boast or praise the Northern Army. Instead, it told a lot of truth, which is not bad. General Robert Lee has not many roles, the main characters are the Southern Army "Stonewall" and the Northern Army's Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain. Through the plot, they show their stories and personal charms in the military and in life, especially "Stone Wall". As an epic film of the American Civil War, I give it 8.7 out of 4 stars!

Gods and Generals quotes

  • Capt. Alexander 'Sandie' Pendleton: [about Jackson] What is it? He's never cried before. Not for all the blood and all the death. Not for his young students from VMI. Not for his friends. Not for anyone.

    Johann Heros Von Borcke: Not so, Sandy. I think he's crying for them all.

  • Sgt. Thomas Chamberlain: [deleted scene, Battle of Antietam] It's good to be Sergeant, isn't it? To shoot a sergeant, you have fire through two men first.

    Sgt. Buster Kilrain: A sergeant never fires his weapon until the men in front of him are killed. And then, only unless you want to show off.