Polanski: I accuse the world: me too

Ken 2022-03-23 09:03:07

Roman Polanski restores the most notorious Dreyfus anti-Semitic incident in French history, titled Zola's open letter to the president of the same name published in Aurora, which defines the "intellectual" Concept: Take criticism as its own responsibility and speak out for justice.

The film uses a super-high level of classicism, for fear that a larger action will disturb the smoke and dust in the historical archives, and reproduces this piece of history that has already been discussed in a smooth and restrained manner. Elegant and neat like a textbook, but also boring like a textbook. History is quietly evolving and transmuting, hiding thunder in the silent place, hard and heavy, resisting and counteracting every effort to find the truth.

In the movie, the waves are calm, but outside the movie, the waves hit the shore. Polanski uttered "I accuse" and was met with a "Me too" response - first, the Caesar Awards caused the resignation of the entire board of directors due to the film's 12 nominations, and then the director and starring of "Portrait of a Burning Woman" at the closing ceremony of the Caesar Awards of public protests. Fortunately, the film was luckier than its own biography, and "I Accused" finally won the Venice Film Festival Jury Prize and the Caesar Best Director Award, escaping the misfortune of "alternating justice in the name of justice".

View more about An Officer and a Spy reviews

Extended Reading
  • Marcel 2022-03-15 09:01:06

    #Venezia 11I am not a person who knows real historical events in particular. I have a feeling similar to when I watched "Barry Linden": the objects, costumes, light sources, street scenes, and character behaviors of that era are restored in detail. The gentle monotony of the first half highlighted the ups and downs of the ending, and several court scenes made people look angry. Perhaps Polanski knows that his "accusation" will not be able to get a "just" trial in the end, but this kind of cold-eyed observation with the best of effort and intertextuality in and out of the play is still quite embarrassing.

  • Vincent 2022-04-21 09:03:07

    Polanski's choice of an unexpectedly small entry point for such a complex and influential Dreyfus case proves that the purpose of the film is not simply to borrow money, as many had assumed. The film defends itself and pleads its grievances. Picard is indeed fighting hard for Dreyfus' innocence, but the whole process is very cold and restrained, there is no montage of night battles for justice, and there is no sensational drama that is often common in this type. Out of the "official" attitude. These de-heroic dispassionate handling proves that the larger theme of "My Complaint" points to this "public", this system that hides filth and hides filth and protects each other. Picard is not a messenger of justice, but a competent screw. He replaced Dreyfus in prison and took us through a trial full of traps. / "I accuse" of the parallel paragraphs are shot with full force, each paragraph is a close-up and a long-range, and the accused read out their guilt.

An Officer and a Spy quotes

  • Picquart: I want to see the Dreyfuss file.

  • Picquart: Dreyfuss is innocent.