dog-tailed mink

Yvette 2022-11-10 18:58:54

I liked this movie a lot until I watched it for an hour.

Although the Poirot here is unsmiling, his expression is as serious as a detective who came out of SCI. But overall, the picture is pretty good.
It was just a little bit of delay ahead, and I anxiously waited half an hour for the murder to happen.
Can that reasoning be complete in the next hour?

It turned out that my worries were completely unnecessary, the director not only finished the story in 90 minutes, but also had the mind to do other things (because he didn't intend to show the reasoning process at all). For example: elevate the theme.

That's why it's been rated Samsung again and again.
As a loyal supporter of an old grandmother, I cannot tolerate any violation of the original book: since Poirot still firmly believes in the absolute supremacy of the law when he discovers the truth, why should the film copy the original book's description of the two The treatment of this explanation - Poirot of course knew that the first explanation was not valid, and if he hadn't been shielded, he would not have mentioned it.

In addition to the logical flaws, the portrayal of Poirot's contradictory choices also objectively weakens rational deduction. A good detective drama has become an emotional drama.

And it would be fine if the film's understanding of the relationship between legal authority and morality was innovative.
It is not as good as the black and white film "Nuremberg Trials" in the 1960s, with a clear theme, direct and reasonable dramatic conflict. The key is that people know that they are making a movie, not a classroom teaching of the history of legal thought, so they know how to avoid reality and make falsehoods, instead of directly discussing the difference between (new) natural law and analytical jurisprudence, but focusing on portraying the role of judges and expressing personality. Charm can naturally make people fall into the emotion of personal worship, thus ignoring the rational part.

Generally speaking, although this film is not suitable for detective fans who are logically first, the story is quite strong. At the end of the chapter, Poirot chose to lie to the police officer, and he left with his back to the crowd, a line of tears, which was moving.

View more about Murder on the Orient Express reviews

Extended Reading
  • Shaun 2022-03-19 09:01:10

    The seriousness and depression of the new version let us say goodbye to the playful Belgian detective ~ but the thinking about law and justice makes Poirot more like a real person ~ the guarantee of the quality of the British adaptation!

  • Shanon 2022-03-17 09:01:09

    Thanks to David for his wonderful performance, his micro expressions did not disappoint me. The other actors are also collected from the previous classic version. The only thing missing is that in just one and a half hours, some plots are sublimated, and some plots are hidden. It is the best choice to read the old version first and then the new version, so as to understand the forced revisions made by the director to the original. Also, understanding is understanding, but Papa Polo is religious, too. . . . . . . . . .

Murder on the Orient Express quotes

  • Caroline Hubbard: What is it with these men who go around falling in love with the staff?

  • Greta Ohlsson: Some crimes God does not forgive!