huge bug

Johathan 2022-04-19 09:01:14

Finally, when Malfoy was about to kill Dumbledore, Harry met Snape downstairs, who was about to go up. Snape signaled Harry not to speak, and then went upstairs to kill Dumbledore. At that time, there were Bella, Fenrir and other Death Eaters upstairs. If Snape was really Voldemort's loyal servant, why did he remind Harry not to make a sound? Even if he didn't kill Harry because he wanted to leave him to Voldemort, was it really normal behavior for a Death Eater to do nothing to him? With that in mind, how could Harry be completely unaware of it later?

View more about Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince reviews

Extended Reading

Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince quotes

  • Ginny Weasley: Take my hand.

  • Harry Potter: [after looking at Slughorn's memory of Tom Riddle in the Pensieve, sees Dumbledore] Sir...

    [Dumbledore holds his hand out then slows turns away and sits on the step with shock in his face]

    Albus Dumbledore: This is beyond anything I imagined.

    Harry Potter: You mean to say he succeeded, sir, in making a Horcrux?

    Albus Dumbledore: Oh, yes, he succeeded, all right, and not just once.

    Harry Potter: What are they, exactly?

    Albus Dumbledore: Could be anything. Most commonplace in objects.

    [Dumbledore goes to his desk and pulls out a couple objects]

    Albus Dumbledore: A ring, for example, or a book.

    Harry Potter: [recognizes it] Tom Riddle's diary.

    Albus Dumbledore: It's a Horcrux, yes. Four years ago, when you saved Ginny Weasley's life in the Chamber of Secrets, you brought me this. I knew then this was a different kind of magic; very dark, very powerful. But until tonight, I had no idea just how powerful.

    Harry Potter: And the ring?

    Albus Dumbledore: Belonged to Voldemort's mother. Difficult to find--even more difficult to destroy.

    [shows Harry his own blackened hand]

    Harry Potter: But if you could find them all, if you did destroy each Horcrux...

    Albus Dumbledore: One destroys Voldemort.

    Harry Potter: But how would you find them? They could be hidden anywhere.

    Albus Dumbledore: True, but magic, especially dark magic...

    [Harry touches the ring, which spins quickly by itself until it stops]

    Albus Dumbledore: ...leaves traces.

    Harry Potter: [after a long pause] It's where you've been going, isn't it, sir? When you leave the school?

    Harry Potter: Yes. And I think perhaps I may have found another. But this time, I cannot hope to destroy it alone. Once again... I ask too much of you, Harry.