Is the judge responsible for carrying out the bad law of the country?

Daron 2022-04-19 09:02:13

Is the judge responsible for carrying out the bad law of the country?
The common principle of criminal law in every civilization is that anyone who encourages the murder or is the accessory of the murder is guilty, even though it is for the benefit of the country.
Moreover, they do not know the terrible result, because they do not want to know. They tried to make them innocent by ignorance.
In the end, the line said that the Nuremberg trials held in the American zone ended July 14, 1949. There were 99 defendants sentenced to prision terms. However in 1961, no one is still serving his sentence. What an irony!
However, I admire Doctor Earnest, who was brave enough to admit his guilt and shoulder the responsibility. But it may be the most terrible thing to tell a judge that the first man you sentenced to death was innocent.
And as the judge said to the defendant counsel, to be logical is not to be right.

View more about Judgment at Nuremberg reviews

Extended Reading
  • Maurine 2022-04-23 07:02:33

    The appearance of Montgomery Clift is that the concept of justice and law and the individual's speculation about the responsibility of the state after the massacre of the war machines of different countries are the most important issues in the post-war political and legal philosophy system. The two cases discussed in the next film are broken. And the adultery case unfolded wonderfully

  • Freda 2021-12-30 17:21:44

    The American attitude towards the outcome of the Second World War is still inevitably caught in the German attitude. But the essence of the film really shocked everyone: war is not about oneself, no one can be alone. It cannot be assumed that the law does not blame the public or uses ignorance as an excuse to evade one's own obligations or responsibilities. It is very likely that a country is a sinner of war!

Judgment at Nuremberg quotes

  • Mrs. Bertholt: I saw Mr. Perkins today. He told me they'd showed those pictures in the courtroom. Col. Lawson's favorite pictures. He drags them out at any pretext, doesn't he? Col. Lawson's private chamber of horrors. Is that what you think we are? Do you think we knew of those things? Do you think we wanted to murder women and children? Do you believe that? Do you?

    Judge Dan Haywood: Mrs. Bertholt, I don't know what to believe.

    Mrs. Bertholt: Good God. We're sitting here drinking. How could you think that we knew? We did not know. We did not know!

    Judge Dan Haywood: As far as I can make out, no one in this country knew.

  • Mrs. Bertholt: One can't live with hate, I know that. Dan, we have to forget, if we are to go on living.