why should i leave

Imelda 2022-04-19 09:03:13

I cried when we saw the ending, because that's what we wanted and it didn't come easily.
But I never figured out why Jane Eyre left. Does love have to be attached to marriage to be able to reflect its existence? She left because she couldn't face Edward's wife and couldn't marry her? Was it because they struggled only to continue their platonic love in the spiritual realm outside of marriage? I don't understand that two people who love each other like this have to be separated only because of this form of imprisonment.
When Jane Eyre expressed her love for Edward, she was so relentless. At that moment, even if the sea was dead, there was no way to separate them. But when the truth was revealed, Jane Eyre seemed to collapse. But at this moment, I don't think anything major has changed. At this moment, Edward did not reduce his love for her in the slightest, and at this moment, she did not reduce his love for Edward in the slightest. But this fact has since changed their fate. I asked myself: Does Jane Eyre want Edward's love, or the title of Edward's wife? Does she want a love, or a marriage?
If love cannot lead to marriage, is it bound to perish?
I don't understand this inner battle, or this kind of plot caused by a social ideology in that era and regional context.
I followed my own thoughts: if I were Jane Eyre, I would stay, because at that time, he was more vulnerable than me, he would need me more, and he would love me.

View more about Jane Eyre reviews

Extended Reading
  • Jonatan 2022-04-03 09:01:11

    This version of the adaptation takes Jane Eyre and Rochester's views on love and equality far ahead of their time. But in any case, it is still very touching, each episode has small details that make people cry, and the key plots are also handled with a degree of relaxation. ps The actor who plays Rochester feels a lot like Beethoven_(:з"∠)_

  • Zita 2022-04-02 09:01:14

    Reservation, elegance, intelligence and self-confidence are almost the common characteristics of heroines in British classical novels, but why are there always all kinds of beauties in the film, but it is not the heroine's turn...

Jane Eyre quotes

  • Jane Eyre: Sir, I need to have a leave of absence for a week or two, to see a sick lady who's asked for me.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: What sick lady?

    Jane Eyre: Her name is Reed. She's my uncle's wife.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: Uncle? You told me you had no family.

    Jane Eyre: My aunt cast me out when I went away to school.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: Why?

    Jane Eyre: Because I was poor. And she did not like me.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: And she sent you to Lowood without so much as a word or a visit in nearly ten years. So why does she suddenly want to see you now?

    Jane Eyre: Her son John is dead. He ruined himself. She's now struck down with his misfortune. I'll only be gone two weeks, I hope.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: Two weeks? That's not possible.

    Jane Eyre: You have company, sir.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: Very well. But promise me, you'll not stay with this undeserving aunt more than a week.

    Jane Eyre: I cannot promise you. She is dying. I cannot set a time on that.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: Of course, you'll go. I haven't got the power to stop you. You must have some money. Can't travel without money. I haven't given you any salary yet, remember? How much have you, Jane, in whole the world?

    Jane Eyre: Five shillings, sir.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: Here, take fifty pounds.

    Jane Eyre: No, Sir. You only owe me fifteen. I have no change.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: I don't want change, Jane. You know that. Take your wages.

    [Jane nods no]

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: You're right. Better not give you all that. You might stay away for three months. Here. There's ten. Wasn't that enough?

    Jane Eyre: Yes, sir. But you still owe me five.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: Then, come back for it.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: Sir, I have to ask you something else, a matter of business. You have as good as said you intend to be married.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: Really? That has been settled then, has it? You've decided that Miss Ingram is to be my bride. Now I see it. You're going to prevail upon that miserable family to find you a new situation. Ungrateful girl, admit it!

    Jane Eyre: No, sir. I've told you they do not like me, sir. To offer such a service... I shall advertise.

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: Devil, you will! Advertise! I wish I'd only offered you a sovereign, not ten whole pounds. Give me back nine.

    [Jane puts her hands behind her]

    Edward Fairfax Rochester: Jane, I have need of it.

    Jane Eyre: [smiles, her hands still behind her back] No, sir. I do not trust you.

  • Edward Fairfax Rochester: Give me back nine. Jane, I have need of it!