A short comment from the social security work

Kaci 2022-11-28 15:17:13

Britain is a high-welfare country, and there is no doubt about it before or after watching the movie. But also because of this, there will be stories that are different from our country, which is ridiculous, and even sighs. Black is an extreme example in this context.

Because it is a high-welfare country, they have a "temporary relief house" (the one the hostess lives in) allocated by the government. Even if the house is not good, it can still be sheltered from wind and rain. But the opposite is that in order to maintain this welfare system, high expenses are required, and ordinary taxes alone cannot be maintained. Therefore, there is a "bedroom tax" that a male owner needs to pay, which is unimaginable. Its original intention is good-the family conditions of bedrooms with multiple bedrooms are generally good. In order to make the poor live better, these people with good conditions should help the poor who cannot live in the same country. But this greatly hurt the middle class. Even people like Black who cannot work and cannot receive unemployment benefits and employment support allowances.

Going back to the central character of the film, Black, he is the one who has been miserable by this system. The government welfare department has handed over the medical insurance approval to commercial companies that employ no medical knowledge. Commercial companies like Black’s questions are universal. , But it does not possess particularity and does not recognize the certificate issued by a professional doctor. In addition, the verification process is complicated and inflexible, resulting in the consequence that the problem is difficult to solve. Black is an example, but it is precisely because of reasonable existence that tells the world where the flaws of this system are. Their unemployment allowance is given to people who are able to work and who are working hard to find a job but cannot find a job temporarily. Employment support allowances are given to sick groups who have successfully passed the medical insurance approval. What about Black? He seems to be a person outside the system, and no system can protect him. This system has been achieved in terms of fairness, but it is difficult to have conditions outside of the regulations. At this time, his response will be very slow, and even seem unsympathetic.

This is a tragedy that can only occur under the specific background of a high-welfare country. He tore a hole in the high-welfare, institutionalized country that people have long pursued, so that we can get a glimpse of the tragedy within.

View more about I, Daniel Blake reviews

Extended Reading

I, Daniel Blake quotes

  • China: Dan, they'll f@ck you around, I'm warning you. Make it as miserable as possible. No accident. That's the plan. I know dozens who have just given up.

    Daniel: Well, they've picked the wrong one if they think I'm gonna give up. I'm like a dog with a bone, me, son.

  • [first lines]

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: Good morning, Mr Blake. My name's Amanda. I've got a couple of questions here for you today to establish your eligibility for Employment Support Allowance. It won't take up much of your time. Could I just ask firstly, can you walk more than 50 metres unassisted by any other person?

    Daniel: Yes.

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: Okay... Can you raise either arm as if to put something in your top pocket?

    Daniel: I've filled this in already on your 52-page form.

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: Yeah, I can see that you have but, unfortunately, I couldn't make out what you had said there.

    Daniel: Yes.

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: Can you raise either arm to the top of your head as if you are putting on a hat?

    Daniel: I've telt you, there's nowt wrong with me arms and legs.

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: Could you just answer the question, please.

    Daniel: Well, you've got me medical records... Can we just talk about me heart?

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: D'you think you could just answer these questions?

    Daniel: Okay.

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: So was that a yes, that you can put a hat on your head?

    Daniel: Yes.

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: Okay, that's great... Can you press a button such as a telephone keypad?

    Daniel: There's nowt wrong with me fingers either... I mean, we're getting farther and farther away from me heart.

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: If we could just keep to these questions, thank you... Do you have any significant difficulty conveying a simple message to strangers?

    Daniel: Yes. Yes, it's me fucking heart. I'm trying to tell you but you'll not listen.

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: Mr Blake, if you continue to speak to us like that that's not gonna be very helpful for your assessment... If you could just answer the question, please.

    Daniel: Yes.

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: Okay... Do you ever experience any loss of control leading to extensive evacuation of the bowel?

    Daniel: No. But I cannot guarantee there won't be a first if we didn't get to the point.

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: Can you complete a simple task of setting an alarm clock?

    Daniel: Oh, Jesus. Yes... Can I ask you a question? Are you medically qualified?

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: I'm a health care professional appointed by the Department of Work and Pensions to carry out assessments for Employment and Support Allowance.

    Daniel: But there was a bloke out in the, er, in the waiting room, he says that you work for an American company.

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: Our company's been appointed by the Government.

    Daniel: Are you a nurse? Are you a doctor?

    Amanda the Health Care Professional: I'm a health care professional.

    Daniel: Listen, I've had a major heart attack. I nearly fell off the scaffolding. I wanna get back to work, too... Now, please, can we talk about me heart? Forget about me arse, that works a dream.